American Idol

[Karrie]

Allison was GREAT!

I was a Danny Gokie fan - but I dunno- Adam is starting to win me over...

I kinda worry that Adam is conforming for the sake of the contest? Anyhow, he's getting better with each show....

[MyFairLacy]

allison was amazing! She is consistantly great every week! Everyone else was just ok tonight. I like Adam better when he tones it down.

[yorkiepaws]

Allison and Adam are my top favorites, but I like Danny too!

[sandyapk]

I have liked Allison from the beginning. Adam annoyed me at first, and now I simply love him. Every week he has been reinventing himself. I am happily surprised he moved away from the punk screaming tongue thrusting Steven Tyler. ( lol thats a llittle strong.) I wonder who the final two will be.

[crystalsmom]

To answer your question yorkiesmiles, as far as I'm concerned Danny was ok but I'm not a fan and no matter what Kris sings I love (Judges liked both of them)

When Allison sang I really thought it was her night. A 16 yr old kid to sing with that emotion is really something to behold but at that point I did not expect the performance from Adam that came later. He was magnificent and unless he gets sick and drops out, there is no doubt in mind that he is the winner. I am a little bummed out because there is no chance for Kris now but after last night Adam blew me away.

I did not get alot of the judges judging last night. Scott? Matt? (he was nervous and off key through alot of the song) and Anoop? Lil?

[alaskayorkie]

I agree. Love Allison, but I find myself not being able to wait to see what Adam's going to come up with. Everything he does is unique. I don't even particularly like that style of music, but he does it so well that I can't help be a fan of his.

I think he could have done a believable job singing any of the songs everyone else did. But I don't think anyone could come close to pulling off what he did tonight.

He's your winner. Anyone wanna bet?

[crystalsmom]

Mike, we both posted at exactly the same time

[cpuff35]

At this point...it seems like Adam is a sure winner. He far surpasses all the other contestant and is a "TRUE ARTIST". There really is no competition except for the spot for 2nd runner up, which I hope it goes to either -- Allison, Danny, or even Kris.

I agree, it's time for Scott to go and I'm beginning to dislike Lil, so I hope she goes soon as well. I really don't think Lil has stepped up to the game. After one boring karaoke performance after another, she tells the judge she's going to step up her game but I have NOT seen any improvement since top 12.

[crystalsmom]

Originally Posted by cpuff35

At this point...it seems like Adam is a sure winner. He far surpasses all the other contestant and is a "TRUE ARTIST". There really is no competition except for the spot for 2nd runner up, which I hope it goes to either -- Allison, Danny, or even Kris.

I agree, it's time for Scott to go and I'm beginning to dislike Lil, so I hope she goes soon as well. I really don't think Lil has stepped up to the game. After one boring karaoke performance after another, she tells the judge she's going to step up her game but I have NOT seen any improvement since top 12.

I agree with you about Lil, I just didn't think she deserved 4 judges with negative opinions (3 enough) I didn't mean to put Scott down with a ?, he really was pretty bad.

[shirlblack]

I thought both Allison and Adam were great last night as usual. Matt also did good but I was disappoointed in Danny's arrangement of his song even though I am a fan.

They were running out of time again last night partley due to Paula's ramblings. Four jusdges is one to many.

[shirlblack]

Originally Posted by cpuff35

At this point...it seems like Adam is a sure winner. He far surpasses all the other contestant and is a "TRUE ARTIST". There really is no competition except for the spot for 2nd runner up, which I hope it goes to either -- Allison, Danny, or even Kris.

I agree, it's time for Scott to go and I'm beginning to dislike Lil, so I hope she goes soon as well. I really don't think Lil has stepped up to the game. After one boring karaoke performance after another, she tells the judge she's going to step up her game but I have NOT seen any improvement since top 12. :rolleyes:

I agree it's time for Scott or Lil to go. Both are just so mediocre every week and show no signs of improvement.

[Trixter]

Adam is so ready for a record deal!
Allison was fantastic last night, and although the outfit was kindof old for her I did like it better than last week. I like her hair and think she pulls it off. I agree, that emotion from a 16 year old, to be able to sing that song the way she did, she will go along way.
Danny was good, but I don't think anyone can touch Adam at this point. Chris did a good job, I think he and Matt are competing for the same fan base though, and one of them will be in the bottom 3 tonight.
Matt stepped up and seemed a little more Justin Timberlake, but I think the judges were over the top on him.Maybe they were just excited that he came around?
Scott was awful, I'm glad the judges called him out on it. I do believe he deserves kudos for getting up there.
Lil will be in the bottom as well. I really had high hopes for her in the beginning, but Tina Turner was kind of predictable. She did look great though.
Almost forgot Anoop! I liked the song, think he'll be safe, and was glad he made the apology. UNC will move him through to the next round.

[Lou]

Mark my word! LIL is going home. She and Scott will be in the bottom three. As far as I am concerned it was Allison's night last night and Danny came in at almost a dead heat with her. I missed Adam's song since he sang last but I don't like him anyway. LOL

[dogbert]

We were gone last night till late we didn't see any tv at all. Glad you guys can fill me in!

[Sookie]

I thought Adam was simply AMAZING last night. He is so incredibly talented and last night his was the only song where I actually listened with rapt attention. I thought Danny and Allison were very, very good. I still like Matt a lot. The rest of them are mediocre IMHO.