Americn Idol Fans...

[Keno]

Originally Posted by mojo

Ok seriously, what is Paula on???????? I missed the first 10 mins., but then I tune in, one of them sang and then she was talking about how somebody did a bad job on both songs and they're like, he only sang one song. And she looked so confused. Can't she be normal for a one hour program??????????

They actually watch the rehearsal and take notes. Paula was in a time warp.

[kalina82]

Originally Posted by mojo

Ok seriously, what is Paula on???????? I missed the first 10 mins., but then I tune in, one of them sang and then she was talking about how somebody did a bad job on both songs and they're like, he only sang one song. And she looked so confused. Can't she be normal for a one hour program??????????

Also, hate to say this, haven't like him all along, but really starting to like David C.

I don't know if many people know this, but Paula is on heavy medication because she has chronic pain. she usually says stupid things but last night was bad. omg i laughed but it was kinda sad too, ya know?

[mojo]

Originally Posted by Monday

IMHO, Jason should be packing his bags for Music Camp. And Brooke will follow next week. Or visa versa. But neither will be in the top 3 (as far as I am concerned)

.

Hey now!!!!!!!!! Jason can pack his bags for my house - I think he's a doll!

[mojo]

Originally Posted by kalina82

I don't know if many people know this, but Paula is on heavy medication because she has chronic pain. she usually says stupid things but last night was bad. omg i laughed but it was kinda sad too, ya know?

Actually, I know she is, BUT, she cant go 1 hour??

[Shelby&Seymour]

Originally Posted by mojo

Hey now!!!!!!!!! Jason can pack his bags for my house - I think he's a doll!

I think that he will stop here, too. ( He would make a great "pool boy")

[Betty'sMom]

I'm sad for Brooke, I can't help it. Really and truly, Jason should have gone home. He's not even trying.

[kalina82]

Originally Posted by mojo

Actually, I know she is, BUT, she cant go 1 hour??

LOL guess not. i thought she looked "off" tonight too when Ryan was doing the live phone calls with her.

[kalina82]

i'm happy to see Brooke go. Jason better be next.

[LuvmyYorkies2]

I figured it would be either Brooke or Jason...it was kinda sad though...I think the most emotional departure thus far...

[For My Coby]

Originally Posted by Shelby&Seymour

I think that he will stop here, too. ( He would make a great "pool boy")

Okay, he can leave the best for last - MY HOUSE!

I thought Jason looked a bit more animated tonight - maybe it just suddenly "sunk in" where he's at and what's at stake. I really like his voice - I still think it's just his laid back attitude that confuses people. Either that or he'd been drinking. ....kidding!

But David Cook still just................. rocks!!

[crystalsmom]

Originally Posted by For My Coby

Okay, he can leave the best for last - MY HOUSE!

I thought Jason looked a bit more animated tonight - maybe it just suddenly "sunk in" where he's at and what's at stake. I really like his voice - I still think it's just his laid back attitude that confuses people. Either that or he'd been drinking. ....kidding!

But David Cook still just................. rocks!!

Needless to say I'm glad Brooke was the one to go. I love Syesha but I think she will be the next to go.

Seems you and I and many others still love Jason. His 'over the rainbow' and 'september morn' and his smile is so endearing.

David C. is not enjoying this and I think this is why I am enjoying him less. I think this may come down to David C. and Jason and of course David C has been my favorite since day one . Just my mixed up crazy opinion.

[MeganS]

Paula...oh my. I saw that last night and I was just like...what is she smoking..lol. Oh well.

I am beyond annoyed about Brooke going home. I mean, I loved her, but I am irritated that she went home and Jason is still there. Sorry to all the Jason-lovers, but I've never liked him...and I don't think I will. I was expecting Jason to go this week, Brooke to go next week, Syesha to go the week after, and then it would be a toss up between David A. and David C. - I have no clue who will win. I felt really, really bad for Brooke, though feeling bad for someone isn't a reason to keep them in the competition, and that seemed to be why a lot of people voted for her.

Yesterday I paid attention and I tried to put my finger on what exactly it is about Jason that bugs me...and I just can't figure it out. He was even a bit more of a performer this week, but I just don't enjoy him. Ah well. If he wins though...I won't be watching next year. Sorry.

[crystalsmom]

Don't worry Megan he won't win and you will be with us next year

[mojo]

It was so time for Brooke to go!!!!!!!!!!! I don't like to see them so upset and sad however.
I never liked, oh, your kicked off, by the way, would you mind singing for us?

[Yorkiefan49]

I still think Simon made that comment to Syesha last night about her being voted off on purpose!! And I think it worked!! I think he said it in hopes people would disagree and call to vote for her! And she stayed. Talent wise, Jason really does need to smile beautifully, sing us a sweet song and go home next. Syesha and the Davids are a very well deserved top three IMO!! Go David C.

Also, someone said earlier David C doesnt look like he's having fun....I see how it looks that way, but Im kinda thinking maybe he is trying to be humble. I think he wants to show more enthusiasm, but he hasnt found the perfect median of showing excitement yet remaining humble.....hope he does cuz Id like to see some more excitement from him too. I think he is just an amazing talent!