So upset, PLEASE give opinion

[AmyChristine]

to me it sounds like this dog is going to need alot of work to be a good family pet. I also feel like temperment is the most important deciding factor. If you dont love her attitude than I think you should look elsewhere, especially with children in your home. There are so many adult yorkies out there that love people and just want to be loved, yorkies tend to be social and I feel like this girl hasn't been very well socailized. Good luck in your search, I am sure that you will find "the one." I am sorry to hear about your son, sending prayers to you and your family.
-Amy

[ARCHIE]

There is no way you can determine a dog's behavior in a parking lot.
The poor dog was taken from it's owner and put into the hands of a
stranger. This dog is already one year old and attached to it;s family.
How do you think the dog should have acted? I think it acted accordingly,
being held by an unfamiliar person. In the dog's defense, I think it did nothing
that any other dog would have done, in this situation.
Buddy is a love and loves people but if I handed him over to someone he did
not know I am sure he would growl at that person being unsure what was
happening.
You need to spend time with the dog alone. Only puppies don't care who
holds them IMO.
I am sorry your son has been sick and glad to hear his treatments have
worked and he is on his way to recovering. That is wonderful news.
Good luck,

[Yorkiekids]

It doesn't sound like a situation I'd want to be in.

[amandawash]

This statement I am about to make is SOOO generalized and is likely to get me flamed but all the min pins I have been around have been NIPPY! I have only been around 4 of them (all different owners) but they have all been the super protective type and didn't like strangers. I don't know anything about them but maybe that's common?

I sure wouldn't want a dog in need of all sorts of rehabilitation at a time like that in your life though- I KNOW there is a PERFECT baby just waiting for you and your family. It just may not be quite the perfect time in your lives. Trust me though, when it is the perfect time, the perfect dog will appear.

Prayers for your son, sounds like he is doing great!

[Bhikku]

I would not buy any puppy which growled or snapped at me while I was interacting with it for the first time. Especially if it did it looking me in the face (dominantly) and not out of fear.

I personally turned down a Chow mix rescue puppy that did this, and the rescue people were very put out because I had been ready to sign the paperwork and everything, but ultimately it's an animal you're going to have to live with for years and you shouldn't feel pressured into adopting a dog that is going to cause problems for you.

[mscat]

Hi there and Welcome to YT! i am very sorry that your dealing with so much right now, and your child being so ill. i hope the best for you and your little boy.
I have A 10 month old Yorkie puppy, and she is the most sweetest little dog in the world. SHe loves people, rarely barks, and just wants to be around us at all times. All dogs have different temperments, just like people.
I would definately keep looking for a better , more nicer Yorkie . The one you looked at was a mix that has Guard dog characteristics. I'd stay clear away from that one.
Getting A Yorkie a yr. or older does look like it will work for your family. Look at the temperment of the dog, because I feel like this is very important. your going to want to try and find a good match.

[Fancy_Pants]

Originally Posted by sabina

In your situation, I think getting a yorkie, or any other dog, would be tro ublesome for you and the dog would be a burden, unfair to the dog. Parking lot and the reality surrounding the introduction would be unfavorable to the outcome. Dogs can read the emotional state of a stranger and act accordingly. Watch Cezar Milan????!!!best of luck, Sabina

I didn't ask you if I thought getting a yorkie or any dog would be troublesome for me. I think IF I am looking for one the right one and have been for several months now the dog would NOT be a burden to me or be unfair to the dog! I never said I was emotional or anything and by the way I DO watch Cesar Millan, every Friday at 8pm thank you very much. (Maybe you don't though, because you didn't even know how to spell his name correctly)

~Shelly

[Fancy_Pants]

To everyone else the above post was not regarded to you. I appreciate everyone giving me their opinion, thank you. I do appreciate your prayers also.

I think I will keep searching for the right one. I do think with time she would come around but I'm not sure I want to deal with the growling. Being timid would be one thing but growling and being unhappy is something else entirely.

~Shelly

[cheryl19]

Originally Posted by gracieanna

I wouldn't get a dog who behaved that way at one year old. At least, not unless I was willing and able to put a lot of re-training effort into him/her. And it isn't just the time and effort, it's knowing what to do!

I am so sorry to hear your son is ill. If I had a child fighting cancer, I might choose a dog that would be less challenging since I would already have my hands full! Also, a dog that is already afraid of people wouldn't be ideal for small children while being "retrained" -- retraining often only goes so far. Some dogs have early experiences that are never completely forgotten.

[janelles]

Originally Posted by ARCHIE

There is no way you can determine a dog's behavior in a parking lot.
The poor dog was taken from it's owner and put into the hands of a
stranger. This dog is already one year old and attached to it;s family.
How do you think the dog should have acted? I think it acted accordingly,
being held by an unfamiliar person. In the dog's defense, I think it did nothing
that any other dog would have done, in this situation.
Buddy is a love and loves people but if I handed him over to someone he did
not know I am sure he would growl at that person being unsure what was
happening.
You need to spend time with the dog alone. Only puppies don't care who
holds them IMO.
I am sorry your son has been sick and glad to hear his treatments have
worked and he is on his way to recovering. That is wonderful news.
Good luck,

Well said, and I agree.

[143julz]

Plain and simple, IMO, that wasn't the right dog.
You'll know when the right one comes along and won't have to ask for opinions.

GOOD LUCK TO YOU in your search

[Wylie's Mom]

Honestly, I would wait for the right furbaby to come along. One that is easy going and okay w/ a stranger petting it (with its owner right there). Get one that you meet, and FALL IN LOVE WITH . It's just so wonderful when that happens.

All the best to your son's health - I can't fathom what you must go through. Hugs.

[MeAndMyOlivia]

I would also advise to keep looking - it's best to go with your first instincts (speaking from experience with NOT going with my first instincts!). These types of behaviors can be very challenging to manage. There is a little furbaby out there that is meant just for you and your family. Blessings to you - glad your son is nearing the end of his treatments.

[MauiGirl]

Sounds like you have made the decision to keep looking for the right one. Like many others that have posted, I totally agree that this didn't sound like a good start. To me growling shows fear, agression, or sometimes illness. It would not be a happy experience for your family. You will find a dog that adores you.... and that's how it is supposed to be.

Best of luck to you, and to your son in his recovery.

[Lucia]

I think you will know instantly when you find the yorkie for you so I want to wish you lots of luck I wish your son all the best with his recovery, and hope he'll soon have a furry friend to play with! xx xxx