Stupid question regarding supplement ingredient

[107barney]

Originally Posted by my2boyz

I think it was the last part about continuing to feed my dog an unbalanced diet...it sounded like I have been doing it forever and I haven't. The diet I feed her 'is' balanced...meat and veggies...she can't have grains. My reason for asking about the supplement is because I know she has to have the proper nutrients in her diet...I'm just trying to find the right ones that will work for her.

Since I have a highly allergic dog with many problems, I understand your frustration. But, what you are feeding - meat and veggies - without supplementation is not a good idea even short term. That's all I really meant here. I even offered you a suggestion! Here's another one: use human supplements if you don't want to purchase balance it or another veterinary product.

[BabyGirl Rosie]

I use the Balanceit supplement. I purchased it as a suggestion from the recipe I got from Dr. Remillard. I think it is a good supplement for home cooking as I home cook myself. My Rosie has IBS and the recipe and supplement we are using has worked wonders for her.

In 107barney's reply, I think she just meant that if you are feeding home cooking without a supplement even if it is a vet recommended recipe, the supplement is used to "balance" it out. Any home cooked meal, in my understanding, needs supplements in order for the pup to get everything needed. I don't think she was meaning it in a rude way. Just saying that since you are a determined individual you will get the right supplement your pup needs. She is very knowledgeable in regards to home cooking. I have to give her lots of credit for getting me started. She can be a great asset to you on home cooking.

[my2boyz]

I bought NV Organic chicken frozen raw patties this afternoon so she will be getting everything she needs. I am also waiting to hear from a rep at Darwin's for a menu consult.

I looked at the Balance It ingredients list but wondered about the powdered cellulose??

[BabyGirl Rosie]

What is Powdered Cellulose?

[Ellie May]

It sounds like things are being switched up often. So if it is partially food related abd possibly enviro too, why not start with a hydrolyzed diet? How long has she been on a hydrolyzed veterinary diet alone with no treats or chews?

We have been here too. It is miserable. ...but there is hope if you are methodical and strict. Ellie used to chew her paws for a half hour at a time. Not anymore...