For sale threads

[PrestigeousYT]

Originally Posted by fannie

I really don't feel that it needs to be gotten rid of completely. I DO feel that sellers need to be upheld to higher standards so that people CAN find reputible breeders here.

What is the High Standards that the Admin holds on the featured Breeders??

deana

[fannie]

Originally Posted by PrestigeousYT

What is the High Standards that the Admin holds on the featured Breeders??

deana

There aren't any. That's the problem.

[PrestigeousYT]

Originally Posted by fannie

There aren't any. That's the problem.

Yes that is quite a problems since they state that they are held to a higher standard.
YIKES

Deana
Prestigeous

[MyTrixie143]

Originally Posted by CC's

A long time ago listing available pups by members for other members seemed ok.

Now it seems to just be another advertising site for many.

IMO no pets should be sold on this site at all. There are plenty of places on line to advertise pups. It shouldn't be done here.

Get it back to just a group of people enjoying others with like interests.

I have to disagree with that. If it weren't for YT I would have never met Linda or got Destiny. And there are many others who will agree as they have found their yorkies because of breeders on YT.

As with any breeder you need to do your research. YT has become a great tool for helping others find reputable breeders.

But I do agree with more guidelines, but I think it may be tricky to do.

[peanut]

Like I said get rid of it and go back to the old forsale forum, that way there are no expections for new people that don't know anyone

[CC's]

Originally Posted by MyTrixie143

I have to disagree with that. If it weren't for YT I would have never met Linda or got Destiny. And there are many others who will agree as they have found their yorkies because of breeders on YT.

As with any breeder you need to do your research. YT has become a great tool for helping others find reputable breeders.

But I do agree with more guidelines, but I think it may be tricky to do.

There is a nursery section. If you see a pup you might be interested in you could always approach the breeder privately. Also people put their webpages in their signatures. You could look them up that way.

I guess I have the most problem with the featured section.
It gives the impression these breeders are recommended by YT and above questioning by members. Anyone can make a pretty webpage and appear anyway you like.

Unless there is someone from YT admin. who truly inspects each breeder there they should be open to scrutiny by all they are advertising to.
Any breeder who sells pups to the public should have to answer to the public. Especially if they are advertising on a discussion board.

Then if someone wants to buy from them they at least have the benefit of seeing the discussion and making a better informed decision.

[Ladymom]

Originally Posted by Mardelin

I agree

I also agree.

I belong to a Maltese forum and sales of live animals are not permitted. When you remove that element from a forum, it makes it much easier to educate potential puppy buyers on how to find a reputable breeder.

It doesn't stop sales behind the scenes. Members often contact a breeder who is member when they are looking for a puppy because they have gotten to know them through their posts. This way the sales are kept private between two people with no implied endorsement from the forum.

[PrestigeousYT]

This is a thread that shows that people think featured breeders are recommended by YT
And I can see how someone would think that.
http://www.yorkietalk.com/forums/sho...d.php?t=109807

Deana
Prestigeous

[MyFairLacy]

Originally Posted by Ladymom

I also agree.

I belong to a Maltese forum and sales of live animals are not permitted. When you remove that element from a forum, it makes it much easier to educate potential puppy buyers on how to find a reputable breeder.

It doesn't stop sales behind the scenes. Members often contact a breeder who is member when they are looking for a puppy because they have gotten to know them through their posts. This way the sales are kept private between two people with no implied endorsement from the forum.

I'm a member of the same Maltese forum and the attitude there is night and day from YT in regards to breeding practices. Everyone there is so educated on what a reputable breeder is and does such a good job of educating others. Since I've joined, I haven't seen too many breeding debates on there.

[fannie]

I just now read through that entire mess and I can totally see what you're saying Deana. Now I went through the featured breeders section and see that it YT itself made a mistake in saying

Featured Breeders are held to a high standard and provide a great level of customer service for YorkieTalk members.

That is in the YT Featured Breeders List.

Featured YT Breeders must be Donating Members first before they can be a Featured YT Breeders. We require Featured YT Breeders to offer a one-year health guarantee. The health guarantees and the Yorkie selling contract must be viewable by any potential buyers.

We require YT Featured Breeders to have at least one year experience breeding Yorkies, or have personally handled at least two previous Yorkie litters already before they can join the program.

Those are the only requirements to be a featured breeder. Those obviously aren't high standards. That's what we're hoping to change.

[MyFairLacy]

Originally Posted by fannie

I just now read through that entire mess and I can totally see what you're saying Deana. Now I went through the featured breeders section and see that it YT itself made a mistake in saying That is in the YT Featured Breeders List.



Those are the only requirements to be a featured breeder. Those obviously aren't high standards. That's what we're hoping to change.

I really hope admin will read this and consider changing the featured breeder policies.

[admin]

Thank you for your feedback. We periodically review the For Sale forum rules. The YT Featured Breeders are not in any way recommended by YorkieTalk, it was created because there were professional breeders that wanted to differentiate themselves from the Yorkies for Sale forum, which was getting crowded. The only fee is for listing Yorkies in the Featured forum and YT makes no commissions nor do we collect any money when Yorkies are sold. We believe a breeder may price their Yorkies at any price they wish, and buyers may choose to buy or not buy at that set price. We are not saying any Yorkie is worth more than any other Yorkie, but there is a discrepancy in Yorkie puppy prices from one state to another, as we have seen puppies as little as $300 or as high as $5000. All potential buyers should do their homework and ask questions before purchasing any pet.

The reason that only serious questions may be asked and only positive comments may be made is because there were other breeders who only posted to harass YT Featured Breeders, which is unfair. We believe the Yorkie For Sale forums are necessary and helpful, as many Yorkies have found wonderful homes through our For Sale forums.

The higher standard required of Featured Breeders are that they are required to offer a one-year health guarantee, contracts must be openly viewable, and they must have experience breeding Yorkies. This is what the YorkieTalk team decided on after consulting with YorkieTalk members on what should be required for a Featured YorkieTalk Breeder.

It is simply impossible for us to verify breeding stock, dam/sires of the Yorkie puppies, or other additional information from breeders.