Americn Idol Fans...

[Laur]

Originally Posted by SaraAlexine00

Anyone notice how amanda did not sing with the group tonight? wonder why??? (that was sarcastic!)

I noticed she was even't singing with the rest of the group, they showed her and her lips weren't even moving, she looked bored or annoyed!!!! Her hair looks like a skunk!

[TatumsMom]

Originally Posted by Laur

Yeah I saw that...I think he started later than he was supposed to and she got all ticked off!

Well, after watching a couple times, I could see that he was fumbling with his guitar strap or something. She did shoot him a vicious look though!

[Keely's Mommy]

We like David A and David Cook then for the girls its Carly and Brooke White.

I don't care for Amanda. I couldn't understand anything she ever sang.

Jason Castro he's strange. When he sings he moves his head like the Brady Bunch kids would do when they sang. I can't help but laugh everytime I see him cause thats all I think about.

I really think a guy is going to win this year. The girls just aren't strong enough.

[Laur]

Originally Posted by Keely's Mommy

We like David A and David Cook then for the girls its Carly and Brooke White.

I don't care for Amanda. I couldn't understand anything she ever sang.

Jason Castro he's strange. When he sings he moves his head like the Brady Bunch kids would do when they sang. I can't help but laugh everytime I see him cause thats all I think about.

I really think a guy is going to win this year. The girls just aren't strong enough.

When Jason sang that song with the French in it, I couldn't help but laugh. Whenever they interview him, he has no clue what to say. Him and Brooke could totally be in the Brady Bunch the way they act.

[Keely's Mommy]

Originally Posted by Laur

When Jason sang that song with the French in it, I couldn't help but laugh. Whenever they interview him, he has no clue what to say. Him and Brooke could totally be in the Brady Bunch the way they act.

Oh yea she could too. LOL!!

[Janie616]

I am quoting from another message board regarding AI.

http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,2000...5286_2,00.html
Garth, meanwhile, expressed his dismay at David Archuleta's front-runner status:

''He is really getting dull and painfully predictable.
It's like when a dog shoots out one puppy after another.
The first couple are cute, then after that, all you can think about is
'How am I gonna get rid of all these puppies?"

I loved the analogy.

[Monday]

Originally Posted by TatumsMom

I just have to say he's a doll to look at! I honestly think if it weren't for the dreadlocks, he might be too "pretty" to be a boy! The dreads add that "something interesting" to him though.

TMZ thinks he is a look-alike of Melissa Gilbert of "Little House on the Prairie".

AI Jason-Gilbert_littlehouse_corbis_getty.jpg

What do you think????

[cheeselover8481]

Originally Posted by Keely's Mommy

We like David A and David Cook then for the girls its Carly and Brooke White.

I don't care for Amanda. I couldn't understand anything she ever sang.

Jason Castro he's strange. When he sings he moves his head like the Brady Bunch kids would do when they sang. I can't help but laugh everytime I see him cause thats all I think about.

I really think a guy is going to win this year. The girls just aren't strong enough.

I agree with you on this. Only difference with your list and mine is that I have Sayesha on my list 2.

[Betty'sMom]

Originally Posted by Monday

TMZ thinks he is a look-alike of Melissa Gilbert of "Little House on the Prairie".

Attachment 204860

What do you think????

His teeth are nicer!!!!!

[shuber]

LOVE LOVE LOVE David Cook. David Archuletta is very talented too, but I think he sounds too much like everything else on the radio now.

Out of the Girls I like Carly Smithson the best. Amanda Overmyer is good too, but she sounds alot like janice joplin and she can't really change her voice for different styles of music.

I can't put my finger on the reason, but I can't stand Brooke White. She is like this years Sanjaya to me.

[kalina82]

I too was surprised that Carly was in the bottom three last night. She is awesome. i love her voice. Once again tho, i was disappointed that christie lee cook did not get voted off. i think she is horrible, absolutely horrible. glad amanda got booted. her voice was annoying.

my picks for Idol are David Cook, Carly, and Michael Johns.

LOVE David Cook!

[mojo]

Originally Posted by shuber

LOVE LOVE LOVE David Cook. David Archuletta is very talented too, but I think he sounds too much like everything else on the radio now.

Out of the Girls I like Carly Smithson the best. Amanda Overmyer is good too, but she sounds alot like janice joplin and she can't really change her voice for different styles of music.

I can't put my finger on the reason, but I can't stand Brooke White. She is like this years Sanjaya to me.

I think that is the girl I dont like too....reminds me of a hippy, artsy type.

which one is carly? I am just not good at names.

[Janie616]

Originally Posted by Betty'sMom

His teeth are nicer!!!!!

ya think???

[teri88]

Originally Posted by Monday

TMZ thinks he is a look-alike of Melissa Gilbert of "Little House on the Prairie".

Attachment 204860

What do you think????

OMG! That is hysterical. And....very true!

[teri88]

Originally Posted by shuber

LOVE LOVE LOVE David Cook. David Archuletta is very talented too, but I think he sounds too much like everything else on the radio now.

Out of the Girls I like Carly Smithson the best. Amanda Overmyer is good too, but she sounds alot like janice joplin and she can't really change her voice for different styles of music.

I can't put my finger on the reason, but I can't stand Brooke White. She is like this years Sanjaya to me.

...except she can sing! I loved her in the begining, but I'm getting tired of that tilted head, bedroom eyes thing she does to the camera. Just sing lady. Just sing.