Americn Idol Fans...

[Jenn218]

Originally Posted by Duncansmom

is it just me or does Brooke remind you of Carly Simon?? I like Carly (the irish girl), David A David Cook and Brooke. I think Carly is the most consistant. The rocker chick forget her name, is getting on my nerves now.

Duncan and Pipers mom

I think so too....especially when she did You're So Vain!
I have liked all of her songs....until last night...it just wasn't that good.

[Jenn218]

Originally Posted by Jody Renfroe

Just a side note on David Cook (by the way, I think he's great!). Our local Tampa entertainment reporter was talking to him and told him that his little girl, who is fighting leukemia, was his biggest fan. David got on our reporter's cell phone and called her and talked to her. If you noticed last night, he was wearing an orange bracelet on his left arm. It's a bracelet all of the little girl's family and friends are wearing which has her motto on it "Do what you have to do!" I thought that was just such a sweet thing to do.

That is great...he seems like he is a great guy! Doesn't he do something for his brother too? Like, if you see an "AC" on his guitar, that stands for his brother? I can't remember?!

[Sookie]

I like Carly and David A. I think David A will win because he really appeals to the young girls and whoever signs him will make a ton of money from David A! Plus he's talented.

[For My Coby]

Originally Posted by Monday

..........He is a good guy! I wish Ryan would ask him about it so everyoine would know!

I wonder if there's a place at the website where you could email that in??

[Laur]

I LOVE David A. and really like David Cook. David Cook reminds me of Daughtry. For girls, I like Ramiele, Brooke, and Sayesha. I'm sorry but I can't stand Amanda...she is getting under my skin, literally She sounds like she is screaming ALL the time, she has the WORST smokers voice and all she can do is rock, do something else. I was so happy when the judges told her it's getting old and she needs to change it up. IMO, all she does is scream and yell, no talent and she just annoys me.

[Jody Renfroe]

Originally Posted by Jenn218

That is great...he seems like he is a great guy! Doesn't he do something for his brother too? Like, if you see an "AC" on his guitar, that stands for his brother? I can't remember?!

I didn't know anything about the "AC", just the orange bracelet! I thought he did really well last night, but David A. gives me goose bumps when he sings. Such a pure voice!

[MeganS]

I've been in love with David since he auditioned.

I've been in rehearsals since basically the beginning of the Idol season this year, so I only know a few of them. Now that my show's done, I'm finally getting into it!

[SaraAlexine00]

I think David Cook is AWESOMEEEEEEEEEE!!!! He's going to get signed whether he wins or not, that's for sure. Although, I do think David Archuleta will win the competition. Usually the girls are always my favorite, but this year its the guys! I do really like Carly tho... she's got an amazing strong voice.

I just searched Katherine McPhee's "somewhere over the rainbow" on youtube so i could listen to it again from season 5.

[JCarlson2004]

Originally Posted by Laur

I LOVE David A. and really like David Cook. David Cook reminds me of Daughtry. For girls, I like Ramiele, Brooke, and Sayesha. I'm sorry but I can't stand Amanda...she is getting under my skin, literally She sounds like she is screaming ALL the time, she has the WORST smokers voice and all she can do is rock, do something else. I was so happy when the judges told her it's getting old and she needs to change it up. IMO, all she does is scream and yell, no talent and she just annoys me.

I just can't stand Amanda either!! She screams and she only sings in ONE style. She isn't versatile at all. I lower the volume whenever she sings.

[Laur]

Originally Posted by JCarlson2004

I just can't stand Amanda either!! She screams and she only sings in ONE style. She isn't versatile at all. I lower the volume whenever she sings.

LOL, everytime she comes on me and the fiance say, "Oh god here we go..." HAHA, it's like no surprise with her b/c every week she just does her screaming thing.

[Janie616]

Originally Posted by ARCHIE

It was so bad I shut the tv off and went too bed!
I have had enough of the Beatles. Even Simon said it last night.
I think only the Beatles can sing their own songs to begin with.
Most, to me anyhow, are just plain dumb!
To stick these poor kids with this kind of music and expect them
to sing like they did is also dumb!
I think they should let them pick their own music to begin with.

well said.
Someone else said that earlier and I thought about it.

and the same with Janis Joplin
(sorry Amanda, you are just screaming, Janis had her own style)
They say there is nothing worse than a poor imitation!

[Jody Renfroe]

and the same with Janis Joplin
(sorry Amanda, you are just screaming, Janis had her own style)
They say there is nothing worse than a poor imitation![/QUOTE]

Amen!! I loved Janis Joplin and I'm old enough that I actually heard her live! She was one of a kind!

[Nancy1999]

Say will you east coast girls post the results as soon as you find out, I like impressing my family with my predictions.

[Shelby&Seymour]

I didn't thnk that ANY of them really stood out and were totally AWESOME....

Of course, he didn't sound that great (and who would want to SING the Beatles.... 2 weeks in a row!!)... but Jason Castro is too cute to be voted off.... that face... oh MY!!!!

Amanda reminds me of a chick singing at a biker bar.... and that is fine if you're a biker and like rocker chicks.... but she is NOT an "American Idol".

I guess we will know soon!!!

Good Luck to MY Favs... JASON CASTRO and Brooke White!!

[Shelby&Seymour]

Originally Posted by Nancy1999

Say will you east coast girls post the results as soon as you find out, I like impressing my family with my predictions.

LOL........YOU Houdini YOU!!!