To Administration

[Sugar's Mom]

Originally Posted by txshopper73

Actually, I'd much rather like to see that the pups need to be 12 weeks before they can be advertised. But, 10 weeks is such a big step and I'm happy for it. But, this is JMO.

i know what's wrong with you. you just want me to keep mine forever. LOL You know I'd like to anyway.

[MeganS]

I'm undecided on how I feel about this.

However, I don't think they should say how many posts there should be. People do "spam" posts (posts that are just one word..etc.) all the time. There's a way to wrack up your post count. and plus, not everyone has enough TIME to be on here often enough to make that many posts.

JMO.

[txshopper73]

Originally Posted by Sugar's Mom

i know what's wrong with you. you just want me to keep mine forever. LOL You know I'd like to anyway.

hehehe! And, there's something wrong with this??? LOL! I'm with you...I've got 3 little ones, too that I'd like to keep forever BUUUT, hubby would kill me!.

[chachi]

Originally Posted by txshopper73

Actually, I'd much rather like to see that the pups need to be 12 weeks before they can be advertised. But, 10 weeks is such a big step and I'm happy for it. But, this is JMO.

Me too. It was a huge step and I am sure he knew he was going to have some unhappy members that are breeders

[Gingergirlsmom]

Originally Posted by txshopper73

I'm going to play devil's advocate here for a minute. I like the new rule. I think it's better for the pup though may not be so good for the breeder. Here's why...

Some breeders like that commitment when the pups are at a young age. Someone sends you a deposit, etc. What happens if the pup cannot be adopted out? What happens if the pup (though had a fine bite at 2 weeks) at 8 weeks has turned into an overshot or undershot bite. I hope that the breeder is going to take less for the pup...if they're going to sell it at all. You can tell A LOT more when a pup is older and closer to adoption age. I don't like seeing very young pups advertised on YT from any breeder. BUT, that's JMO.

I've sold 2 of my pups to YT members and here's how I did it...I start posting picts of the pups as they progress. If someone is interested, they'll pm me. There's really no reason to advertise the pups for sale at all. In the time I've been a YT member, I've posted one for sale ad and to be honest, I'll never do it again. There are so many threads in the for sale section here, it's reminding me of a flea market.

So, I'll duck from flying rocks now. I know I've probably ticked some people off, but that's okay. Just that my opinion is different from some.

I haven't yet read this entire post, but was glad to see your post. I'm not a breeder, but I had my own business for years, and this is what I believe:

If YT said you could advertise them before 10 weeks, but run a disclaimer, there would be NOTHING to stop people from pming each other and letting the advertised pups go before 12 weeks. How would YT possibly enforce it???

I also like your idea of showing the pups in the nursery. Anyone interested in a new pup is probably glued to that forum anyway...

I know it probably seems like a harsh rule. But, it does seem like a good way to safeguard the pups, and afterall, isn't that what everyone wants. I also think it'll deter those breeders off who pop in here just to sell their pups but never visit any other time.

This is jmo, and I don't mean to offend anyone. Interesting topic!

[Little Bit]

Originally Posted by txshopper73

hehehe! And, there's something wrong with this??? LOL! I'm with you...I've got 3 little ones, too that I'd like to keep forever BUUUT, hubby would kill me!.

So...Kimberley, does that mean you have puppies available?

Nancy

[Susanbee51]

Originally Posted by txshopper73

You're absolutely right! I wish that member had to have a minimum of let's say...100 posts (not in the for sale section) before they could post their litters. Posting litters is a privilege...not a right!

If there was a 100 post rule then I just made it. WHEW!!! Oh wait a minute, I don't have any puppies and my Tigger never will since she had that taken care of a month ago.

[Susanbee51]

Originally Posted by Willow

I guess I really do not understand the holding puppies until they are 10 weeks old?? Our last litter the puppy was weaned by 6 weeks and had his first shots then and would have been ready to go to his new home at 8 weeks, but they weren't able to get him until he was 13 weeks. Legally, puppies can go to their new homes at 8 weeks.

I really do not think it is the admins place to say "you can't let your puppies go or take deposits on them until they are 10 weeks old." Now before you flame me, and say it is for socialization of the puppy, I really think that depends on the puppy. Autumn wanted NOTHING to do with Chewy once she weaned him. She didn't want to play with him or anything and we didn't have any other puppies for him to "socialize" with, so there really was no socialization reason to keeping our puppy to 13 weeks.

I discussed with my vet and another breeder I know and they both agree that 8 weeks (as long as the puppy is healthy and eating and has a normal development) is a good age to go to their new homes.

It was VERY hard letting Chewy go. He was 3 months old and not only had he bonded with us, but we bonded with him and he was somewhat stressed over leaving with strangers. He has adjusted now, but I would prefer my puppies going to a new home around 8 weeks of age so that they are not bonded with my family before going with their new family. IMO, the longer you keep them, the more bonded and attached the family and the puppy are to eachother and the harder it is to let them go to a new home. JMO.

Start throwing your stones.

Please don't think I am throwing a stone. I am not. I didn't read that admin said you couldn't take deposits or let your puppies go at 10 weeks. Admin cannot control what a person does outside of YT. They just said that no one would be able to post puppies younger than 10 weeks of age in the For Sale section.

My little girl was 6 weeks old when I got her. I have learned so much on this forum about puppies and wish that my little one would have remained with her mommy a bit longer. I have been able to compare the difference between my little girl and puppies from birth to 12 weeks of age, when they go to their forever home. What a major difference. My little one I feel was cheated. JMO.

[Willow]

Originally Posted by Susanbee51

Please don't think I am throwing a stone. I am not. I didn't read that admin said you couldn't take deposits or let your puppies go at 10 weeks. Admin cannot control what a person does outside of YT. They just said that no one would be able to post puppies younger than 10 weeks of age in the For Sale section.

My little girl was 6 weeks old when I got her. I have learned so much on this forum about puppies and wish that my little one would have remained with her mommy a bit longer. I have been able to compare the difference between my little girl and puppies from birth to 12 weeks of age, when they go to their forever home. What a major difference. My little one I feel was cheated. JMO.

I understand what you are saying. I got my Autumn at six weeks and she would have been better kept until atleast 8 weeks, IMO. I don't think any puppies should go before 8 weeks of age.

[luvdorkyyorkies]

Im not sure what the benefit of the 10 week rule is really. Why 10 weeks? I agree a puppy should never leave their mother sooner then 8 weeks, preferably 10-12 weeks minimum stay but 8 weeks is legal in states who do have puppy age laws.
I guess Im just confused how that helps in the for sale thread? I could see a rule against advertising unborn puppies or any puppy under 8 weeks even, but I just dont under 10 weeks. I guess Im missing the point, or the reasoning.
I have used the for sale forum a few times, but it hasnt been common for me. SO its not that.
Unless you are a very frequent poster, alot of people wouldnt know to look in the nursery. If someone posts a puppy that will be available for a home at 6 weeks, doesnt mean they are releasing then. I like looking at the for sale threads, I thought it was fun to see puppies growing and knowing they are available early. Im not in the market to buy a puppy just like looking.
Just curious about the new rule and how 10 weeks came about and just wondered if someone could clarify the reasoning?

[luvdorkyyorkies]

I guess I kinda feel that the new rule penalizes people/breeders/ members it should not, but all with the sincere best intentions.
I see there are some breeders on here who have released puppies to other YT members, advertised early, and the new owners are really happy. These are frequent posters or long time members who take great pride in releasing their puppies to good homes, taking extra measures to try to ensure 100% puppies, and they would stand behind their guarantees. Would probably go the extra mile. For those people under those circumstances, when they offer their puppies, they know they are under a big magnifying glass and they plan on making the transaction more then satisfactory or excellent. Its alot about reputation, truth and intregrity. You cant guarantee some things but you certainly want the puppy and the owner to be happy. Its extremely important to them and they would work with you.
I think member status, such as the number of threads is more fair, not just posts, but threads.

[Sugar's Mom]

I would rather place my babies with yt'ers if possible because you know they are going to good homes but I really need to advertise them earlier than ten weeks so I have time to place them. I have another litter coming the first of Feb and i would love to know that these have been spoken for and are going to good homes when old enough.

[luvdorkyyorkies]

I do not use Yorkietalk for advertisement for my puppies almost never.
I have placed ONE SPECIAL BOY to ONE SPECIAL YT MEMBER.


I just like to state my opinion. Makes me feel very important.

[Sugar's Mom]

Originally Posted by luvdorkyyorkies

I do not use Yorkietalk for advertisement for my puppies almost never.
I have placed ONE SPECIAL BOY to ONE SPECIAL YT MEMBER.


I just like to state my opinion. Makes me feel very important.

I have never placed an ad on here either. just had thought I might this time. Guess not tho.

[luvdorkyyorkies]

Sugar

You must speak to administration.