"Outdoor" Dogs...Is there such a thing? - Page 3 - YorkieTalk.com Forums

Chrissy0277 · 02-28-2008, 05:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by YorkieAunt

So is it okay to leave your dog cooped up in a kennel all day?

This kinda of comment is uncalled for and rude

I must be taking this quote you replied on differently then you taking it. I think dogs shouldnt be kept outdoors all the time, even if they have a dog house. Dogs belong with their family not left outside even if they have an excellent dog house. Kenneled all day no!

Chrissy0277 · 02-28-2008, 05:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SladesMommy

The outside dog is exposed to the elements
It can be stolen, shot, poisoned, attacked by a wild animal, escape, etc

Slade is kenneled in an XL crate (though rarely for 7 hrs) , so by your logic perhaps I should just leave him in the backyard where he would be "happier"?

My uncle left his dog outside in a pen (along with a dog house) outside when he was working during the day. Someone poisoned his dog.

SladesMommy · 02-28-2008, 05:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chrissy0277

My uncle left his dog outside in a pen (along with a dog house) outside when he was working during the day. Someone poisoned his dog.

Exactly my point! The ONE time I left Laney outside while I ran a birthday cake I had made to a friend, I was worried sick to my stomach about the whole time, and the trip took no more than 30 mins. I couldn't work if I knew my dogs were outside getting into who knows what. I would be worried the whole day.

autumn star · 02-28-2008, 05:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hha

Like I said, there are some people that NO, they shouldn't own any dog(even inside ones), but, my outside dogs are just as loved as much as the inside ones, and actually get more human one on one time, than the inside ones...and yes, that was a VERY rude comment she made!

Its not a matter of being RUDE, its a matter of having an opinion! Just like you and everyone else that has posted on this thread! From what I have read on this thread most people are NOT leaving their dogs outside.
If you choose to..............then that is your decision! Sorry that you feel my statement was RUDE but its how I feel!

hha · 02-28-2008, 06:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by autumn star

Im allowed to have an opinion just like everyone else including you. Sorry if you don't like it. If your dog is crated they are usually inside away from the elements of the climate. So to answer your question, yes it would be okay to leave them in a kennel opposed to outside were its hot or cold, snowing or raining!!!!

Sorry, but, mine aren't out in the cold, there very warm thank you, and they don't get wet when it's raining, as the door is closed on their shelter and has a small opening big enough for them to get out of..like I said, mine are treated probably better than your inside dog.

autumn star · 02-28-2008, 06:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hha

Sorry, but, mine aren't out in the cold, there very warm thank you, and they don't get wet when it's raining, as the door is closed on their shelter and has a small opening big enough for them to get out of..like I said, mine are treated probably better than your inside dog.

I highly doubt it! But if it makes you feel better to think that then go right ahead. Do you have a reason to be so defensive? You have your opinion and I have mine! I would Never leave my dogs out and you would! End of story. Don't beat a dead horse! It is what it is!!! I was not accusing you of anything I was just saying how I felt, just like everyone else!

kl1977 · 02-28-2008, 06:32 PM

Dont come to Al then, cause some of you folks are gonna be very disappointed.

Tillys_mom · 02-28-2008, 06:33 PM

What's the purpose in arguing?

You guys are saying the same things over and over. It's getting old.

LuvmyYorkies2 · 02-28-2008, 06:48 PM

I personally would have a big dog inside most of the time. I do understand though that larger dogs (especially if it's their nature), need to be outside more often and/or for longer periods of time, that's if they chose to be. I wouldn't force them out there but I would have to have a big dog constantly couped up in my small house. They would need a lot more exercise then my yorkies. Definitely not in the the rain or non-appropriate weather. I would even want my big dog to be my lapdog just as much as my yorkies..

If people do chose to do it, I would hope they have the best setup possible for them and give them just as much attention as they would any inside dog. I am bothered when I drive or walk by someone's house and I see a big dog, chained to a tree with a little dog house, empty water bowl that they can't even reach anymore, etc.....That's what I would have a problem with.

hha · 02-28-2008, 06:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LuvmyYorkies2

I personally would have a big dog inside most of the time. I do understand though that larger dogs (especially if it's their nature), need to be outside more often and/or for longer periods of time, that's if they chose to be. I wouldn't force them out there but I would have to have a big dog constantly couped up in my small house. They would need a lot more exercise then my yorkies. Definitely not in the the rain or non-appropriate weather. I would even want my big dog to be my lapdog just as much as my yorkies..

If people do chose to do it, I would hope they have the best setup possible for them and give them just as much attention as they would any inside dog. I am bothered when I drive or walk by someone's house and I see a big dog, chained to a tree with a little dog house, empty water bowl that they can't even reach anymore, etc.....That's what I would have a problem with.

Believe me, I have a problem with that too...I can't stand seeing a dog chained to a tree or in a little tiny area where they have no where to run..there is a cocker spaniel across the stree from me, that is tied to a tree, it breaks my heart..I have taken it over treats before when the owners have been gone..that dog never gets walked or played with..My 2 are a long haired shepherd, she is huge, and a golden retriever..the love it when hubby or me goes out and throws the balls for them, they smile and are 2 fantastic dogs, but, they have it made in the shade...hubby always says he really wishes we didn't have dogs, but, since we do, they're going to have the best life they can..our old golden retriever was outside, she lived until she was 18, and then we had her put down due to cancer...

LuvmyYorkies2 · 02-28-2008, 07:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hha

Believe me, I have a problem with that too...I can't stand seeing a dog chained to a tree or in a little tiny area where they have no where to run..there is a cocker spaniel across the stree from me, that is tied to a tree, it breaks my heart..I have taken it over treats before when the owners have been gone..that dog never gets walked or played with..My 2 are a long haired shepherd, she is huge, and a golden retriever..the love it when hubby or me goes out and throws the balls for them, they smile and are 2 fantastic dogs, but, they have it made in the shade...hubby always says he really wishes we didn't have dogs, but, since we do, they're going to have the best life they can..our old golden retriever was outside, she lived until she was 18, and then we had her put down due to cancer...

A cocker spaniel.....OUTSIDE???? ALL THE TIME??? Now if I had a cocker, it would be inside most of the time.....Believe me, I've been tempted to go pet or talk to or take treats to some dogs I've seen chained and left outdoors but they always look like they want me for dinner

since they obviously hadn't gotten any love and attention........so unfortunately that idea fades fast...

daisy mae06 · 02-28-2008, 07:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hha

Believe me, I have a problem with that too...I can't stand seeing a dog chained to a tree or in a little tiny area where they have no where to run..there is a cocker spaniel across the stree from me, that is tied to a tree, it breaks my heart..I have taken it over treats before when the owners have been gone..that dog never gets walked or played with..My 2 are a long haired shepherd, she is huge, and a golden retriever..the love it when hubby or me goes out and throws the balls for them, they smile and are 2 fantastic dogs, but, they have it made in the shade...hubby always says he really wishes we didn't have dogs, but, since we do, they're going to have the best life they can..our old golden retriever was outside, she lived until she was 18, and then we had her put down due to cancer...

I ask this with the up most respect and totally just trying to understand..
If you have Dogs that are outside all of the time in Runs or what ever what is the propose of having them at all.
My dogs Golden Retriever included are inside and Very happy.
the yorkies are in a Pin Huge x pin when we are not home .. just to keep them safe. and Amy the Golden has free roam of the house. she is VERY well behaved. They are our Lives 24/7 not just a 1/2 hour or so a day they sleep with us and lay by our feet /laps.
I just have a Very hard time trying to Figure out how some one can keep outside dogs.. Sorry I do not mean to sound upsetting I am just trying to comprehend it.

RebelBelle · 02-28-2008, 07:18 PM

Despite this thread being a little heated, I'm gonna post anyway. I think that as long as you honestly love your dog and really make an effort to do whats best for them, then thats the end of it. I live in a state where ALOT of people have outdoor dogs. In fact when I was small my grandfather raised hunting dogs. I know people who have large dogs and honestly believe that its inhumane to keep them locked up in a house all day while they are at work, they bring the dogs in during bad weather though. In the evenings they make great efforts to spend alot of time outside running and playing with them. I don't know that its "right" but these dogs sure look just as happy and loved as Jamie. Would I do it? No. But am I going to condemn others for making the decision in the responsible way? Nope. Because there are bigger issues, like people who REALLY abuse and neglect their dogs.

MeganS · 02-28-2008, 07:19 PM

Quote:

I ask this with the up most respect and totally just trying to understand..
If you have Dogs that are outside all of the time in Runs or what ever what is the propose of having them at all.
My dogs Golden Retriever included are inside and Very happy.
the yorkies are in a Pin Huge x pin when we are not home .. just to keep them safe. and Amy the Golden has free roam of the house. she is VERY well behaved. They are our Lives 24/7 not just a 1/2 hour or so a day they sleep with us and lay by our feet /laps.
I just have a Very hard time trying to Figure out how some one can keep outside dogs.. Sorry I do not mean to sound upsetting I am just trying to comprehend it.

Well, it sounds to me like she has them for the same reason we all have ours.

To love on and play with.

genie · 02-28-2008, 07:26 PM

I have a golden (Jake) that is an OUTSIDE dog only and he wouldn't be happy any other way. He is very much a part of our family. He not only gets lots of attention from our family but all the kids in our neighborhood. He has two best freinds Abby (the boxer) and Bailey (the Jack Russell). He has a huge custom made dog house that matches our home and it is very warm and it keeps him dry...so he is not exposed to "the elements". IMO I think that it is cruel to keep a large dog in a kennel for long periods of time. At least my dog can run and play all day. Jake is always happy and playing and he doesn't want to come in the house. We also have an outside cat.

02-28-2008, 06:32 PM	#37
kl1977 YT Addict Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Alabama Posts: 348	Dont come to Al then, cause some of you folks are gonna be very disappointed. __________________ Isabeau "Izzy"

02-28-2008, 06:33 PM	#38
Tillys_mom Spoilin' Tilly & Jack Donating Member Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Indiana Posts: 2,227	What's the purpose in arguing? You guys are saying the same things over and over. It's getting old. __________________ Momma Tilly Money will buy you a pretty good dog, but it won't buy the wag of his tail.

02-28-2008, 06:48 PM	#39
LuvmyYorkies2 Donating YT 1000 Club Member Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Southern Maryland Posts: 1,739	I personally would have a big dog inside most of the time. I do understand though that larger dogs (especially if it's their nature), need to be outside more often and/or for longer periods of time, that's if they chose to be. I wouldn't force them out there but I would have to have a big dog constantly couped up in my small house. They would need a lot more exercise then my yorkies. Definitely not in the the rain or non-appropriate weather. I would even want my big dog to be my lapdog just as much as my yorkies.. If people do chose to do it, I would hope they have the best setup possible for them and give them just as much attention as they would any inside dog. I am bothered when I drive or walk by someone's house and I see a big dog, chained to a tree with a little dog house, empty water bowl that they can't even reach anymore, etc.....That's what I would have a problem with. __________________ Yolanda I Love My Girls Diva & Foxxy & Lexi

02-28-2008, 07:18 PM	#43
RebelBelle Donating YT 2000 Club Member Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Madison, MS Posts: 2,597	Despite this thread being a little heated, I'm gonna post anyway. I think that as long as you honestly love your dog and really make an effort to do whats best for them, then thats the end of it. I live in a state where ALOT of people have outdoor dogs. In fact when I was small my grandfather raised hunting dogs. I know people who have large dogs and honestly believe that its inhumane to keep them locked up in a house all day while they are at work, they bring the dogs in during bad weather though. In the evenings they make great efforts to spend alot of time outside running and playing with them. I don't know that its "right" but these dogs sure look just as happy and loved as Jamie. Would I do it? No. But am I going to condemn others for making the decision in the responsible way? Nope. Because there are bigger issues, like people who REALLY abuse and neglect their dogs. __________________ Misty & Jamie

02-28-2008, 07:26 PM	#45
genie Loves Hannah & Gracie Donating Member Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: washington Posts: 1,752	I have a golden (Jake) that is an OUTSIDE dog only and he wouldn't be happy any other way. He is very much a part of our family. He not only gets lots of attention from our family but all the kids in our neighborhood. He has two best freinds Abby (the boxer) and Bailey (the Jack Russell). He has a huge custom made dog house that matches our home and it is very warm and it keeps him dry...so he is not exposed to "the elements". IMO I think that it is cruel to keep a large dog in a kennel for long periods of time. At least my dog can run and play all day. Jake is always happy and playing and he doesn't want to come in the house. We also have an outside cat.