Stickey post?

[SoCalyorkiLvr]

With all due respect, I did not take it off topic....Goldenray did. I did respond as did others.

[gymbo68]

Please show me where I said you did....with all due respect-

[BamaFan121s]

Originally Posted by gymbo68

Please show me where I said you did....with all due respect-

An even better request...Please show me where Goldenray is the one that took it off topic, cause I honestly can't find it. I am assuming that you are not referencing the one where she stated she didn't know what a sticky was. IMO, that comment in no way spawned the novel-length research that followed.

[SoCalyorkiLvr]

Originally Posted by gymbo68

Please show me where I said you did....with all due respect-

Your post #45 where you quoted my post #44 and then said "you" when referring to me..

This is what you said :

"you chose to take it off its original topic and continue your early s/n thread in another place"

I am the one with the Early Spay Neuter thread so you couldn't have been referring to anyone else.

Goldenray took it OT in her post #22.

Did I miss something?

[Sherry Lynn]

Originally Posted by SoCalyorkiLvr

For me, we need a lot more discussion on the issue before it is resolved as a "good" thing for "every pet pup" imo. I don't mind it being a "sticky" as long as the discussion can continue.

I mean we have not addressed the fact that some vets feel a dog has MORE health benefits from not being neutered, or the fact that there are alternatives to a full neuter as we in the US are used to. There is tubal ligation, removal of just the uterus in the female for example and vasectomy for the boys...all of which are less invasive, and less risky but still leave the animal incapable of reproducing. I would like responsible breeders to consider some of these options which I feel benefit the pups.

:zip: Post #20 :zip:

[SoCalyorkiLvr]

Originally Posted by Sherry Lynn

:zip: Post #20 :zip:

This was not OT because I was explaining my reasons for not making it a "sticky" yet. I wasn't writing those things to discuss them in that thread but merely to state what some of the issues were that were not discussed yet.

[PlatinumYorkies]

Originally Posted by SoCalyorkiLvr

This was not OT because I was explaining my reasons for not making it a "sticky" yet. I wasn't writing those things to discuss them in that thread but merely to state what some of the issues were that were not discussed yet.

So Goldenray post was, because she questioned what Vet would say what you stated in post #20. This isn't a debate nor politics, however you can't just pick out only the post that suits your agenda, and opinions. The poster is a breeder if I am not mistaken, and have a history of doing ESN!

[red98vett]

Well...Since this is a NEVER ENDING DEBATE - I'll add my 2 cents.

The breeder section was a NICE place to come and read about what REAL BREEDERS had to say... and a place to learn about breeding... and seeing help offered for new breeders.

SoCal - all over this site you state YOUR views and never let anyone else have their own without looking for a reason to argue and it's seriously getting old.....

It is now a DEBATE section geared toward one persons views and it's overtaking this section. I haven't seen hardly any breeding posts since this freakin LONG debate over spay neuter started

Now it sounds like you're in high school and completely childish with this latest - 'who did what when' ... WHO CARES who took something off topic ? we all do it .......I just can't you pointing fingers Kim when you do this Yourself all the time.

I think I'm taking a break from here for a while till this part of Yorkietalk gets back to what this section is for - BREEDING ...and it isn't someones podium or a place to get all political because YOUR vet said this or that.

It's a place where usually someone can say something without worrying about getting into a serious debate.....There are so many people reading all this and shaking their heads...laughing actually.... and no one is posting about what this section is for. Which is BREEDING.

If I get suspended for this - fine....but this has gone on now for days and it's really getting SILLY and boring as anything.

[StewiesMom]

I have an idea. Delete the breeder section all together. It's awful.

[SoCalyorkiLvr]

There are 24 other threads in this section that you are free to participate in.

I only returned to this one because Gymbo said there was question of his I had not answered. I had not been on here all day as I cosidered it done.

Here is his post on the Early Spay/Neuter thread. I guess I shouldn't have taken the "bait" but I think it is rude not to answer someone.

By Gymbo (Post #120 on the ESN thread)
UUGGHH...you girls have fun-
btw Kim I am still waiting for your reply on the sticky thread
I do not remember saying it was you--FYI

this thread is too much for me...I am off..but enjoy your debate/discussions-

[red98vett]

Originally Posted by StewiesMom

I have an idea. Delete the breeder section all together. It's awful.

It's isn't a breeder section anymore - it's the DEBATE section because someone here loves to debate anything and everything.

[StewiesMom]

Originally Posted by red98vett

It's isn't a breeder section anymore - it's the DEBATE section because someone here loves to debate anything and everything.

I concur