Good eBay site - great prices on Bully Sticks!

[MyTrixie143]

Originally Posted by Wylie's Mom

Shoot, wish I would have seen this sooner - I just bought my first bag of bullies from Muttmart bc their prices were a little better than eddieb260 (where I always get them on eBay) - OMG, Muttmarts STINK STINK STINK. It literally smells like they just ate dog poo, and I'm not exaggerating.

I'm going back to eddieb next time.

Oh no!! I just bought a 20 pack from them.
Now I don't know what I will do with them when they get here, I don't want the whole house to smell.
I wonder if there is a way of de-stinking them, lol.

[Wylie's Mom]

Originally Posted by stedmansmommy

OMG!!!! Ann!!! I just saw this thread and was going to reply and give the bad news to the OP that Muttmart's Bully Sticks *DO* stink to HIGH HEAVEN!!!!!! I mean good GRIEF! Holy moly...those things are POTENT!!! I bought the 10 pack of Bullies from Muttmart as well, right before Tatum's surgery (I wanted to get a whole pack of them to keep her busy while she is stuck in her house for 6 and 1/2 weeks!) and I was wondering what the HECK was smelling so darn bad! I mean the smell was *LITERALLY* making me gag!!! And hubby too! I have bought Bully Sticks before that never really had a smell...but once I bought the ones from Muttmart I knew the horrible smell that everyone kept saying that some of the Bully Sticks out there have!

Between both of my babies, they already went through all 10 of them And I swear I had to hold my nose the entire time! UGH!!! I will never again buy Bullies from there - I don't care HOW cheap they are! IMO, they are CHEAP for a reason - lol!

I just ordered 16 of them from YT member AMD who is having a sale on them - I have heard GREAT reviews on hers and everyone here says that they don't smell! Whew!

OMG, THANK YOU for the confirmation , bc they are AWFUL! My hubby actually thought our dogs were eating their POOP, they smelled so bad - and I hadn't even told him these were the "new" bullies. ICK.

I have so many left...argh...and I feel like I should use them, but my gosh - YUCK! STINK STINK and STINK.

I will never order from there again. I told Muttmart how smelly they were, and they said I could send them back -- but my hubby had already cut/sawed them - so I didn't.

I'll be going back to eddieb260 or buy bulk from AMD.

[Wylie's Mom]

Originally Posted by MyTrixie143

Oh no!! I just bought a 20 pack from them.
Now I don't know what I will do with them when they get here, I don't want the whole house to smell.
I wonder if there is a way of de-stinking them, lol.

Look at Brooke's comment too - seriously, will they let you cancel the order? I really would...if you can.

[MyTrixie143]

Originally Posted by Wylie's Mom

Look at Brooke's comment too - seriously, will they let you cancel the order? I really would...if you can.

Thanks, I just sent them an email to ask if I could cancel. I guess we will see what happens.

Any recommendations on where to get bully sticks for a reasonable price?

[Wylie's Mom]

Originally Posted by MyTrixie143

Thanks, I just sent them an email to ask if I could cancel. I guess we will see what happens.

Any recommendations on where to get bully sticks for a reasonable price?

I usually get mine (except for last time, w/ Muttmart) on eBay w/ eddieb260 - I've used theirs for a couple years and have really been happy. They are slightly more than Muttmart, but SO worth it if you think of smell.

eddieb has both bully sticks and steer sticks - so be sure to read the auction title. Steer sticks are cheaper and are fine for my Marcel (he's 3 lbs) - but I like the bullies for Wylie (6 lbs) who is a more aggressive chewer.

Here is eddieb: eBay Store - Alley's Treats: Bully Sticks, Chicken Duck Treats, Bones

[dogears]

I don't remember where I read it but I believe someone said that if you let the bully sticks air out outside they will not smell as bad.

[stedmansmommy]

Originally Posted by Wylie's Mom

OMG, THANK YOU for the confirmation , bc they are AWFUL! My hubby actually thought our dogs were eating their POOP, they smelled so bad - and I hadn't even told him these were the "new" bullies. ICK.

I have so many left...argh...and I feel like I should use them, but my gosh - YUCK! STINK STINK and STINK.

I will never order from there again. I told Muttmart how smelly they were, and they said I could send them back -- but my hubby had already cut/sawed them - so I didn't.

I'll be going back to eddieb260 or buy bulk from AMD.

YES, they *really* are! I just couldn't get over how these things smelled soooo badly! I never even thought of the smell being caused by the Bully Sticks because all the previous Bullies that I had bought (NOT from Muttmart) did not smell at all - so at first I didn't know WHAT was causing that horrid stench! I would always put one in with Tatum while she was in her little house, and I was wondering what in the WORLD was smelling sooo terrible in there - I even looked around for POOP, but there was none to be found! Then finally it clicked that it was those darn NASTY Bully Sticks! Ughhhhhh! It smelled like a mixture of poop and wet, DIRTY (and I mean DIRTY!!!) dog! It was just sooo sickening to smell! Such a shame too, cause they are priced great! But I guess there is a reason why lol..

When my babies finished them off, they did it OUTSIDE! That is the only time I gave the Bullies to them - cause I just couldn't stand to smell them inside! At least when I gave them the Bullies outdoors, there was FRESH AIR, lol!!! WOOF!

I am going to check out the ones from eddieb260 on eBay too - I don't think I have seen those yet! Thanks for the info girl!!

[tjdmom]

I get my bully sticks from AMD on here.
She has a sale right now... here is her thread
http://www.yorkietalk.com/forums/yor...tick-sale.html

I love her bully sticks and they don't smell at all!

[SweetPea53]

I also get my bullie sticks from AMD here on YT and have never had a problem with them smelling, plus my lil one luvs them....

[Britster]

OH NO! lol. I'm going to try to cancel my order!

[Britster]

Originally Posted by tjdmom

I get my bully sticks from AMD on here.
She has a sale right now... here is her thread
http://www.yorkietalk.com/forums/yor...tick-sale.html

I love her bully sticks and they don't smell at all!

I really don't want to buy 100 bully sticks though. Is there any way to just buy like 10?
EDIT. nevermind. I see where you can pick how many!

[stedmansmommy]

Originally Posted by Britster

OH NO! lol. I'm going to try to cancel my order!

LOL - you poor thing! Just be glad we told you! I think neither Ann or myself knew any better when we bought these Bullies from Muttmart, and I'm sure I can speak for both of us when I say that we WISH we would have had someone to warn us before we sent our money for those SMELLY things

I would definitely see if you can cancel...although they may have already shipped out by now

[Britster]

I messaged Muttmart on eBay yesterday with no reply yet! I asked if I could get my money back and said I hoped he hadn't shipped them out already.

I think his return policy said though that you could return them as long as they're how they were before. Yikes... lol, thanks for the warnings, guys! I'll order a few from AMD on here.

[tamaralandau]

I am so glad I procrastinated!!! I just ordered with AMD also. The thought of of Bully Sticks already makes me weak, to have ones that are oderous, I can only imagine why. Right now I am trying to get the visual out of my head. Geeze ...the things we do .....

[MyTrixie143]

Originally Posted by Britster

I messaged Muttmart on eBay yesterday with no reply yet! I asked if I could get my money back and said I hoped he hadn't shipped them out already.

I think his return policy said though that you could return them as long as they're how they were before. Yikes... lol, thanks for the warnings, guys! I'll order a few from AMD on here.

I did the same and haven't heard anything back yet either. I am thinking of giving them a call....