Is Charlie really LOST forever????

[Shanatink]

I was soooooo proud of Hurley, you should have seen me I was jumping up and down screaming with excitement! I love that show!!!




But Im seriously ticked if Charlie is really dead forever

[Sadie's Mom]

Originally Posted by Shanatink

I was soooooo proud of Hurley, you should have seen me I was jumping up and down screaming with excitement! I love that show!!!




But Im seriously ticked if Charlie is really dead forever

Hey, at least your Locke didn't die, right???

[Jenn218]

I bet Charlie comes back...remember, nothing stays dead on that island.

The flashback's, Jack was in the hospital having a fight w/ the doctor, he told the doctor to call his father there and he could fire which on was the drunkest.....but Jack's father is dead!! He was dead in Aust. before they boarded the plane, so I didn't understand that part. ---especially if those flashbacks were the "future"......

I am hoping that some how, Desmond makes it back to the group before they get "rescued"......what a way to end the season....whoa!

So many questions, so many turns, I don't think I can wait until Feb...but isn't that what they did last year too???

[chloeandj]

Originally Posted by Jenn218

I bet Charlie comes back...remember, nothing stays dead on that island.

The flashback's, Jack was in the hospital having a fight w/ the doctor, he told the doctor to call his father there and he could fire which on was the drunkest.....but Jack's father is dead!! He was dead in Aust. before they boarded the plane, so I didn't understand that part. ---especially if those flashbacks were the "future"......

I am hoping that some how, Desmond makes it back to the group before they get "rescued"......what a way to end the season....whoa!

So many questions, so many turns, I don't think I can wait until Feb...but isn't that what they did last year too???

You are very perceptive! I did not catch that about Jack's father, hmmmmm.....!
And who the heck is in that casket that nobody wants to go to the funeral??

[Jenn218]

Originally Posted by chloeandj

You are very perceptive! I did not catch that about Jack's father, hmmmmm.....!
And who the heck is in that casket that nobody wants to go to the funeral??

Well, my DH kept saying that they were showing the future...but then, there was that scene in the hospital and Jack was talking about his father (which should be dead)....then at the end, Jack and Kate were talking and Jack was talking like they should go back? Back where? To the island or were they talking about something else, did they know each other in the past? What??

If it was the future, I figured that maybe the dead person would be Locke or even Ben (since no one came for the visitation) and that Kate was with Sawyer, but I don't know. Would Jack's father not really be dead, even though he was dead before they got to the island??

Who was on the ship that answered the phone call? Are they bad people? What happens to the island? I still think Desmond might get to them and try to change the "rescue" or even tries to do something w/ the signal before the people can find them?? I don't know.......

[Amber_lv]

Originally Posted by Jenn218

Well, my DH kept saying that they were showing the future...but then, there was that scene in the hospital and Jack was talking about his father (which should be dead)....then at the end, Jack and Kate were talking and Jack was talking like they should go back? Back where? To the island or were they talking about something else, did they know each other in the past? What??

If it was the future, I figured that maybe the dead person would be Locke or even Ben (since no one came for the visitation) and that Kate was with Sawyer, but I don't know. Would Jack's father not really be dead, even though he was dead before they got to the island??

Who was on the ship that answered the phone call? Are they bad people? What happens to the island? I still think Desmond might get to them and try to change the "rescue" or even tries to do something w/ the signal before the people can find them?? I don't know.......

It has to be in the future because Kate and jack never met. I think something really bad happened to them at the rescue and some how they are paying a high price to be off the island the person in the casket i have concluded is locke it has to be. Charlie is not dead he is a high profile main character and he will be back i'm sure. i think locke kills ben on the island and they are all ripped from the island by this "rescue group" to whick something trajic and devastating happens to them. Another therory i have is that because the have been found "jacob" protects himself and sends everyone back to before they ruin their lives before jacks dad dies and leaves all them with thier memory in tact and it distroys jack's life???? i don't know