American Idol - Page 8 - YorkieTalk.com Forums

Lou · 03-04-2009, 08:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by michsmith1973

yeah...finally found a place where theres chatter about AI!!! Seems like the majority of yahoo groups I belong too that they aren't into AI or just burnt out with it. I'm still a fan...and watch faithfully every week when its on. I wasn't really impressed tongiht at all with any of them. I agree overall it was the best round of people....but none of them blew me away as did first and second weeks. First week was Danny, who has been my favorite thus far throughout and last week it was Adam. i thought they all did comparably the same tonight....they weren't bad....but they were perfomrances I'd remember either. I really like Scott McIntyre.....but I dont feel like it was his best perfomrance tonight....hopefully he will get through and I think he will do some great things when he gets to sing with the piano. Wild card show ill be intersting to see who they bring back.....I just hope that we dont see the return of Bikini Girl, Tatiana or nick Mitchel....those three totally annoyed me. Anybody know who Felicia Barton took the place of? I was trying to figure out who wasn't on there that was to have made it to the end and I dont remember?

OMG I forgot about bikini girl! I don't think the two female judges would allow her back! What a slut!

As far as last night's show I am really torn. I do think Lil was the best but wasn't really impressed with anyone else.

dogbert · 03-04-2009, 08:31 AM

I missed why she left too thanks for filling me in. I can see why she was disqualified, but if that was the case why did she even try out knowing that would happen. Oh well, someone else got another chance from it and that's a good thing. I thought the first 4 or 5 were just ok then they started to get better after that. But then I have such a head cold I could be wrong.

yorkiesmiles · 03-04-2009, 08:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dogbert

I missed why she left too thanks for filling me in. I can see why she was disqualified, but if that was the case why did she even try out knowing that would happen. Oh well, someone else got another chance from it and that's a good thing. I thought the first 4 or 5 were just ok then they started to get better after that. But then I have such a head cold I could be wrong.

She knew the rules - I think she just wanted to find a way to get her name out there and possibly launch her career

michsmith1973 · 03-04-2009, 10:01 AM

I dont remember her by face but I do remember there being a girl who had her name out there already. That kind of makes me mad when they let people with prior expierence to the business on there anyway. Of course they say that AI is not specifically geared towards finding hiddn talent.....you sort of get that vibe from the show and I just think that people who have already had experience in the business shouldn't be allowed...nor do I think it was even fair of t his girl to think she should be given the chance to try out. I'm like the last poster...I think she did it only to get her name out there and for free publicity.

Miao · 03-04-2009, 11:47 AM

I don't think having prior experience should mean they don't get a chance. If they were terrible enough or under poor management, etc, they deserve a second chance if they did what everyone else did--line up outside for hours for an audition. In the end, the people vote, so I believe it's fair enough. Not all who are fortunate enough to have released albums are what I'd consider great or even good singers and sometimes the good ones don't sell for one reason or another.

She wasn't the first. Carly made it to tour, and she had previously been signed with a different label with a different surname and never got anywhere. Michael Johns had released an album or two in Australia. The current Danny Gokey is a church choir instructor, I believe. And then there were horrible vocal trainers who auditioned in the past, but had sounded tone deaf. There had been bar/lounge and hobby singers, so I don't see the difference. They're all professions but just with different avenues of marketing.

What got this contestant dropped was the fact that she might have been acquainted with the producer(s) thereby possibly influencing the selection process. She did include in her audition form her past, whereas, I believe last season, those "professionals" did not. I specifically recall Carly being one of them and thereby bringing on this talk about the fairness of a veteren entering this competition.

yorkiesmiles · 03-04-2009, 06:48 PM

So, what did you all think of the 3 choices from last night's group? What did you think of the 8 selected for the Wild Card show tomorrow?

I can't believe they threw away one of the Wild card spots on Tatitana -- several of those from last night were better than here - including the blonde country singer and the guy who sang Deliliah. I also was hoping they would have chosen the girl who sang the Jupitar song a few weeks ago.

I thought te end was harsh when they left all those hopefuls upstage without another word & started celebrating on stage.

Tomorrow night will be interesting. I wonder if they will actually announce the 3 tomorrow night or stretch this out & make those 8 to find out & be prepared to sing on Tuesday.

MyFairLacy · 03-04-2009, 10:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by yorkiesmiles

So, what did you all think of the 3 choices from last night's group? What did you think of the 8 selected for the Wild Card show tomorrow?

I can't believe they threw away one of the Wild card spots on Tatitana -- several of those from last night were better than here - including the blonde country singer and the guy who sang Deliliah. I also was hoping they would have chosen the girl who sang the Jupitar song a few weeks ago.

I thought te end was harsh when they left all those hopefuls upstage without another word & started celebrating on stage.

Tomorrow night will be interesting. I wonder if they will actually announce the 3 tomorrow night or stretch this out & make those 8 to find out & be prepared to sing on Tuesday.

I voted for Scott and Lil so I was so glad they made it through! I did not like Jorge at all

There were so many other good singers in group 3..it was a tough group. My other vote was for Kendall...she was too cute and I saw potential for her to be another Carrie Underwood/Taylor Swift type country singer. I'm not really into country but I like the more pop kind like they sing.

I'm really excited about the Wildcard episode! Some of them I was so excited they made it back like Jasmine and Megan Joy..and I'm sure there were others I can't think of right now. I always really liked Jasmine but she just didn't do so well last week, but she's such a great singer. Some of them i really didn't remember...too many to keep up with. and oh man..Tatiana. I still have to say she's a good singer but she is a crazy girl.. I don't blame them for putting her through because her vocals are good but I hope she doesn't make it through to top 12...too many other NORMAL good singers. Her dress tonight looked aweful though didn't it?

michsmith1973 · 03-04-2009, 10:57 PM

Well I watched tonight and i predicted that Lil would get female spot and Scott would get male spot and whoever got third spot was up in the air to me. Like I said previously they were all prety much the same to me.....not very memorable but not totally horrible....well except the guy who knocked the stand over....ok...so that one was kind of bad...LOL I wasn't really all that happy that the third spot went to Jorge.....but not surprised either.

Far as the wild cards....for the most part I thought they did a pretty good job of handing them out. I was really hoping that I'd saw the last of Tatiana.....yes she's a good singer but she's annoying and very self centered. Her personality just ruins her chances of making it very far in this competition i believe for her unfortunately. I could have done without a few of the other wild cards too....such as Anoop who I think may have a voice but his stage pressence is very boaring and the red head Jesse.....isn't she the one who butched the Kim Carnes song Betty Davis Eyes? Eeek!! I would have liked to have seen Matt Betzke (bald headed guy) Felicia (the girl w ho got to take the other girl's place) or Ju'nut come back before I would have picked Tatiana, Anoop and Jesse....and I dont understand why they didn't bring back 12 instead of 8....since the other three shows had 12 contestants. That seemed odd to me. Would have gave a few more a second chance.

All in all....the majority of my faves h ave either already made it to the final 12 or they are in the wild card. I think the only one that didn't make it to either that I'm really bummed about is Matt Betzke and I think he just choose the wrong song this last time and unfotunately that one bad call cost him a chance at the final 12. Danny is and has been throughout my favorite. I also really like Adam, Scott McIntyre and Matt Giraud (who is in the wild card show). i really think that a guy is going to win it this year....the girls just aren't impressive much to me this year.

And did anybody see the racey pics of Adam kissing another guy that were leaked to the media? They seem to think it may hurt his chances of making it far in the competition. I honestly dont care....I still think he's got an awesome voice and he works the stage, so even if he was kissing a tree he's still be one of my faves!! I do however think he may make it bigger on stage than he will on radio.

dogbert · 03-05-2009, 05:58 AM

I didn't like all the choices but they could have skipped Tatianna and it wouldn't have broken my heart. Guess I know when to take a potty break.

Lou · 03-05-2009, 07:23 AM

Well, Howard Stern and his idiots are going ot have a field day with Tatianna now!
"Vote for the worst"

yorkiesmiles · 03-05-2009, 08:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lou

Well, Howard Stern and his idiots are going ot have a field day with Tatianna now!
"Vote for the worst"

I really believe out of the 8 to sing tonight - there are at least 3 better than she is. If they put her thru to the top 12 it's all for ratings & so people keep talking about the show

-- and we all know AI is not above that!

We'll see tonight, but I too would hate to see her in the top 12 - that blubbering last night was the absolute WORST - how does that girl think she could ever be a professional? No one would want to work with someone that cries at the drop of a hat.

She makes it to AI finals - and Saturday Night Live, and all the late night comics have something to imitate.

ARCHIE · 03-05-2009, 08:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lou

Well, Howard Stern and his idiots are going ot have a field day with Tatianna now!
"Vote for the worst"

I can't believe they gave this looney a second chance!
She is such a Drama Queen she belongs on a daytime soap.
Who needs to see her hold her heart each week as cuts are
made and drop down on her knees!
Her voice is decent however her actions take away from her
talent. IMO
I think America did a great job in their choices now let's see
what the judges do tonight.

jmdt · 03-05-2009, 08:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ARCHIE

I can't believe they gave this looney a second chance!
She is such a Drama Queen she belongs on a daytime soap.
Who needs to see her hold her heart each week as cuts are
made and drop down on her knees!
Her voice is decent however her actions take away from her
talent. IMO
I think America did a great job in their choices now let's see
what the judges do tonight.

I completly agree. She's a nut case. She'll be gone (I hope) soon enough. I think they brought her back because it's drama. Keeps people watching. If she makes it I will stop watching this season. I can't take her.

cpuff35 · 03-05-2009, 10:09 AM

I have to agree with all the above comment about Tatiana. She is such a drama queen...although she denied in the previous show that she's like that. And during the 2nd group performance she was acting all weird and trying to be more contorlled. I really think she's bi-polar or something.

Lou · 03-05-2009, 10:14 AM

I don't think she is bipolar but if she is clinically depressed she might cry at the drop of a hat even at good news. hmmmm
Still .....Get her out of there!

03-04-2009, 08:31 AM	#107
dogbert Donating YT 1000 Club Member Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: Southern, MN,USA Posts: 3,271 Blog Entries: 1	I missed why she left too thanks for filling me in. I can see why she was disqualified, but if that was the case why did she even try out knowing that would happen. Oh well, someone else got another chance from it and that's a good thing. I thought the first 4 or 5 were just ok then they started to get better after that. But then I have such a head cold I could be wrong. __________________ Mammadoodle to my Yorkiedoodle Barney and our crazy cat Ms. Sassy Pants. RIP Audrey-Belle Within the heart of every stray lies the singular desire to be loved

03-04-2009, 10:01 AM	#109
michsmith1973 Donating Senior Yorkie Talker Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Indiana Posts: 464	I dont remember her by face but I do remember there being a girl who had her name out there already. That kind of makes me mad when they let people with prior expierence to the business on there anyway. Of course they say that AI is not specifically geared towards finding hiddn talent.....you sort of get that vibe from the show and I just think that people who have already had experience in the business shouldn't be allowed...nor do I think it was even fair of t his girl to think she should be given the chance to try out. I'm like the last poster...I think she did it only to get her name out there and for free publicity. __________________ Michelle proud furbaby momma to my yorkies Jackson and Shelby and cuddly kitty Sammy

03-04-2009, 06:48 PM	#111
yorkiesmiles Donating YT 4000 Club Member Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Iowa Posts: 9,493	So, what did you all think of the 3 choices from last night's group? What did you think of the 8 selected for the Wild Card show tomorrow? I can't believe they threw away one of the Wild card spots on Tatitana -- several of those from last night were better than here - including the blonde country singer and the guy who sang Deliliah. I also was hoping they would have chosen the girl who sang the Jupitar song a few weeks ago. I thought te end was harsh when they left all those hopefuls upstage without another word & started celebrating on stage. Tomorrow night will be interesting. I wonder if they will actually announce the 3 tomorrow night or stretch this out & make those 8 to find out & be prepared to sing on Tuesday. __________________ yorkiesmiles Loved by Bubba & Roxy *Holy, holy, is the Lord God Almighty, who was, and is, and is to come*

03-04-2009, 10:57 PM	#113
michsmith1973 Donating Senior Yorkie Talker Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Indiana Posts: 464	Well I watched tonight and i predicted that Lil would get female spot and Scott would get male spot and whoever got third spot was up in the air to me. Like I said previously they were all prety much the same to me.....not very memorable but not totally horrible....well except the guy who knocked the stand over....ok...so that one was kind of bad...LOL I wasn't really all that happy that the third spot went to Jorge.....but not surprised either. Far as the wild cards....for the most part I thought they did a pretty good job of handing them out. I was really hoping that I'd saw the last of Tatiana.....yes she's a good singer but she's annoying and very self centered. Her personality just ruins her chances of making it very far in this competition i believe for her unfortunately. I could have done without a few of the other wild cards too....such as Anoop who I think may have a voice but his stage pressence is very boaring and the red head Jesse.....isn't she the one who butched the Kim Carnes song Betty Davis Eyes? Eeek!! I would have liked to have seen Matt Betzke (bald headed guy) Felicia (the girl w ho got to take the other girl's place) or Ju'nut come back before I would have picked Tatiana, Anoop and Jesse....and I dont understand why they didn't bring back 12 instead of 8....since the other three shows had 12 contestants. That seemed odd to me. Would have gave a few more a second chance. All in all....the majority of my faves h ave either already made it to the final 12 or they are in the wild card. I think the only one that didn't make it to either that I'm really bummed about is Matt Betzke and I think he just choose the wrong song this last time and unfotunately that one bad call cost him a chance at the final 12. Danny is and has been throughout my favorite. I also really like Adam, Scott McIntyre and Matt Giraud (who is in the wild card show). i really think that a guy is going to win it this year....the girls just aren't impressive much to me this year. And did anybody see the racey pics of Adam kissing another guy that were leaked to the media? They seem to think it may hurt his chances of making it far in the competition. I honestly dont care....I still think he's got an awesome voice and he works the stage, so even if he was kissing a tree he's still be one of my faves!! I do however think he may make it bigger on stage than he will on radio. __________________ Michelle proud furbaby momma to my yorkies Jackson and Shelby and cuddly kitty Sammy

03-05-2009, 05:58 AM	#114
dogbert Donating YT 1000 Club Member Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: Southern, MN,USA Posts: 3,271 Blog Entries: 1	I didn't like all the choices but they could have skipped Tatianna and it wouldn't have broken my heart. Guess I know when to take a potty break. __________________ Mammadoodle to my Yorkiedoodle Barney and our crazy cat Ms. Sassy Pants. RIP Audrey-Belle Within the heart of every stray lies the singular desire to be loved

03-04-2009, 11:47 AM	#110
Miao No Longer a Member Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Savage Garden Posts: 1,147	I don't think having prior experience should mean they don't get a chance. If they were terrible enough or under poor management, etc, they deserve a second chance if they did what everyone else did--line up outside for hours for an audition. In the end, the people vote, so I believe it's fair enough. Not all who are fortunate enough to have released albums are what I'd consider great or even good singers and sometimes the good ones don't sell for one reason or another. She wasn't the first. Carly made it to tour, and she had previously been signed with a different label with a different surname and never got anywhere. Michael Johns had released an album or two in Australia. The current Danny Gokey is a church choir instructor, I believe. And then there were horrible vocal trainers who auditioned in the past, but had sounded tone deaf. There had been bar/lounge and hobby singers, so I don't see the difference. They're all professions but just with different avenues of marketing. What got this contestant dropped was the fact that she might have been acquainted with the producer(s) thereby possibly influencing the selection process. She did include in her audition form her past, whereas, I believe last season, those "professionals" did not. I specifically recall Carly being one of them and thereby bringing on this talk about the fairness of a veteren entering this competition.

03-05-2009, 07:23 AM	#115
Lou Donating YT 3000 Club Member Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: A little town south of Chicago Posts: 4,525	Well, Howard Stern and his idiots are going ot have a field day with Tatianna now! "Vote for the worst" __________________ http://www.its-a-yorkie-thing.com Gracie Skeeter Adie Tyler

03-05-2009, 10:09 AM	#119
cpuff35 Donating YT Addict Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Cresskill, NJ, USA Posts: 1,030	I have to agree with all the above comment about Tatiana. She is such a drama queen...although she denied in the previous show that she's like that. And during the 2nd group performance she was acting all weird and trying to be more contorlled. I really think she's bi-polar or something. __________________ Evelyn, mommy to Cassiopia Titus Orion

03-05-2009, 10:14 AM	#120
Lou Donating YT 3000 Club Member Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: A little town south of Chicago Posts: 4,525	I don't think she is bipolar but if she is clinically depressed she might cry at the drop of a hat even at good news. hmmmm Still .....Get her out of there! __________________ http://www.its-a-yorkie-thing.com Gracie Skeeter Adie Tyler