simple question

[feminvstr]

past experience might be females were always the most affectionate, or males the most forgiving. Of course, opinions are based on experience - and each experience has an important impact.

Males tend to be more steadfast and reliable and less moody. No matter the age, he'll be more likely to act silly and puppy-like. On the other hand he's more likely to try to dominate you, particularly during his first year or so. He'll be more easily distracted during training. The male's genitals are external. This might produce some embarrassing moments if he decides to lick himself in front of children or that "old maid" aunt. Some males are enthusiastic "humpers" and try to mount other dogs, toys or maybe even your foot. Also, most males lift their leg to urinate. This can be a consideration if you have expensive shrubbery or yard ornaments. They can also be territorial, marking anything and everything standing with their "scent". Neutering can sometimes help with these behaviors, but is not 100% effective.

The female is generally much more discriminating than the male. She can be affectionate but when she's had enough she'll move away. She's usually quicker to learn and less distracted during training. She is less likely to wage a dominance battle with you but can be cunning and resourceful in getting her own way. She is much more prone to mood swings than the male. One day she may be sweet and affectionate - the next day reserved and withdrawn or even grumpy. The female, on the other hand has periods of being "in heat" unless she is spayed. During this time she can leave a bloody discharge on carpets, couches, or anywhere she goes. She will be particularly moody and emotional during this time. A walk outside during this period can become hazardous if male dogs are in the vicinity.

A study was conducted by Drs. Benjamin and Lynette Hart of the University of California at Davis (The Perfect Puppy: How to Choose Your Dog by its Behavior). Two groups of dog professionals, veterinarians and obedience trial judges, were given a list of thirteen behavior traits and asked to state whether they thought each was seen predominantly in males or in females. Males scored higher than females for aggressive or controlling behavior (dominance over the owner, aggression to other dogs, territorial defense and snapping at children), as well as for general activity, destructiveness and playfulness. Females, on the other hand, scored higher than males for ease of house-training, obedience training and demand for affection. There was no difference between males and females for excitability, excessive barking or watchdog barking.

Each dog is unique, and all surveys have their limitations. Keeping in mind some general differences, dogs of either sex can be excellent pets, especially with a little help from their genes and some consistent training.

[Babbie]

On the territorial issue...i have to differ. At least in brazil i can tell you that at least 70% of guard dogs and police dogs are female, as they are more defensive of their territory and owner.

With terriers, i guess you will see it with both genders, since it is in the breed itself to be territorial over othe dogs.

[feminvstr]

In the US initially, only male dogs were selected for police work, because the females are lighter in weight, mature later and are often less aggressive. However this policy was revisited when it was realised there can be situations when a lighter, less aggressive dog can be advantageous.

Babbie I was not discussing guard dogs, although many Yorkies think they are big, alas, they are a toy

[mybirdys2003]

:I have always had girl dogs. I don't want a dog lifting his leg and peeing on my furniture. She is completely house broken although it took 9 months. Is very loving, sometimes too much. Won't go anywhere without being right on my heels or in my arms. Very energetic and playful. Loves to snuggle on my lap, but hates toe nail clipping! Pat

[Babbie]

Originally Posted by feminvstr

Babbie I was not discussing guard dogs, although many Yorkies think they are big, alas, they are a toy

I know right...i think they donnou what size is!!! Like they say, yorkies are wonderful alarm dogs!!!!!