|
Quote:
|
In defense of Scotty, I think he is adorable. He actually reminds me of my grandson, Scott, who is 19. I think Scotty is only 17 so I think with age he will just get more handsome. I bet if he had longer hair and some facial hair he would look totally different. I love Scotty's smirky smile. As far as vocals go I don't think Scotty is the best vocalist but AI is more of a popularity contest so you never know who will win. |
I think Casey is a truly talented guy, but I see him with a band, not solo. Jacob...broadway, not the American Idol! James, with you Mardelin...he really get in the zone!!! The other 4 I have no comment on. Not into country music anymore :rolleyes: |
Quote:
|
How is it I've just now noticed this thread?!? LOL I've watched every single season. I didn't read through everybody posts, so not sure what concensus we have going here;) I really like Scotty (I Like country though) but that smirk thing he does drives me a little nuts:rolleyes: I like Lauren alot Miss Pia:( she's sooo talented, but I guess not AI material? I was a little sad to see Paul go, mainly because of his personality, I couldn't help but smile when he performed Jacob belongs on broadway, not top 40 James is really great:) but I'm waiting waiting waiting for him to do an Aerosmith song??:D I like Casey, but I'm not into his style of music Stefano is super talented, but he just needs to lighten up or something Haley, oh Haley lol, I really like her and her vocals can be amazing but the growling is a little overkilled. I can see once or twice in a song but it's like every other note:thumbdown This is IMO the best season as far as talent that was in the top 12 since season 3:) I can't even pick a favorite at this point but my prediction is that it's going to come down to Lauren and James at the final. :D |
Quote:
Exactly, I've been saying that for years about the voting! I don't even think there's a limit at all as long as it's in that 2 hour time frame. I can always just picture all the little teenage girls with their cell phones texting like crazy while my poor 2 or 3 votes for the one who actually sang the best is no match for that:( America's Got Talent has voting restrictions, why can't idol do the same thing to make it more fare? |
I was reading about the comments regarding Lauren's last performance "The Climb." Almost all of them were congratulating her because she sang it "better than the original." I'm sorry, but *I* can sing better than Miley Cyrus. That's not saying much. I wonder if Lauren picked that song strategically? If she did, very smart of her. I still think she does pretty well for her age (Lauren) |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I never liked Miley Cyrus, even before her, let's just say, exhibitionist stage. I used to love watching the Disney Channel (yes, was still watching it at 18 years old lol) and I would change the channel whenever her show came on. She just always rubbed me the wrong way. I prophetized to all of my friends that she would become the next Britney Spears and they all scoffed at me. And here we are, a couple of years later, plagued in scandal, and the most important thing is that I was right :) |
Is everyone ready for Idol tonight? I know I have. I have enjoyed replaying last weeks show throughout this week. Who do you think will go home next? I guess it will depend on how they do tonight but personally I am ready for Haley to go home or perhaps Casey. |
Definitely ready for Casey to go!!! Then Haley..I'm sorry but I thought she butchered Joplin! I could see Janice rolling over..lol But, I don't like Scott either. He doesn't sing that bad, but watching him....:rolleyes: |
Quote:
|
Same as before, My favorites are still James, Casey, and Lauren. i\'d like to see either Jacob, Stefano, or Scotty go. |
It is getting harder to decided. Tonight I think James was the only one that was outstanding in his performance, even though that is not my kind of music. I still love Scotty even though I know it was not one of his best performances tonight. I love listening to Jacob sing, I am not ready for him to leave. I think I am ready for Casey to go or Haley, even though I thought Haley did better tonight. I did not care for Lauren\'s song that much either, it was just okay. |
I was a big Casey fan in the beginning, but I haven\'t liked him in weeks and weeks. I don\'t like James\' style of music, but he\'s the best one left as a performer. He\'s no Adam Lambert, but I find myself looking forward to his performance the same way I looked forward to Adam\'s. He surprises and shocks me regularly. Tonight, James and Haley were the only ones who stood out. I love country, and Scottie\'s voice is amazing, but he\'s starting to feel like a cliche. Oh, oh, oh ... I was a big fan of the new judges at first, but I\'m sick of all the praise. I miss Simon. |
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:34 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright ©2003 - 2018 YorkieTalk.com
Privacy Policy - Terms of Use