|
Quote:
Quote:
|
1 Attachment(s) Im soo soo disappointed in the decision!!! James has never even been in the bottom 2, I just think America got it wrong, what a shame. It always seems the one who could make albums gets tossed off. I dont care for Haley, the way she rolls her voice gets very old, and its not needed in every single song. Kind of gets old. Lauren is cute but again, not quite sure where she would fall into the music industry. And Scotty , I think he has a good voice , he reminds me of Travis Trit ( sp). I do think that James will have a career in the music industry , and would not be surprised if he had offers as early as last night. Maybe for him its better off, if you win AI , you are locked into a contract with them , they get some of your royalties and it cant make your own decisions. Seems like the last few winners have never been heard of, at least I dont remember one good song from them. Anyone else Remember MAD Magazine.. that is all I think about when I see Scotty. |
I am so very sad and heart broken right now about last nights show. I just sat on the couch, and kept saying WTH. It's so not fair. BUT I know he will have a wonderful career. It actually may be better this way as he won't have to abide by what Idol wants him to do. |
I think now you all understand how I felt when Pia was eliminated. Never on the bottom 3 and the one time she is she gets voted off. What are we left with? Sorry to say but those that remain their vocals are OK and I think NONE of them are good performers :rolleyes: Which is sad given all of these weeks they've had to improve... I'm sorry for all you guys that really liked James. I wasn't much of a fan of his (at least not from the beginning), but I think he probably has the best personality/performance/heart out of anyone that is left. The rest of them are just ...bleh AND Haley's attitude when she received criticism is just...disgusting. Now THAT is a DIVA. |
Quote:
|
I have not watched AI this season except for the past couple of weeks. I love Steven Tyler and anything out of his mouth is hilarious. I must say that the decision made by "America" last night is SO,SO WRONG !!:mad: James is without a doubt the best of the bunch. I just hope that he has a career like Daughtry is enjoying. Disappointments like this is why I quit watching. |
Quote:
My exact feelings and i haven't missed a show in years |
It's amazing that we here are almost universally stunned, yet James got voted off. We ARE America, aren't we? I guess the ones who are left must have an organized fan base that votes heavily. I think it's gonna be a boring next couple weeks. I don't care who wins. |
Well James wasn't my favorite but I was surprised and saddened last night as well. I wanted him and Haley to be the top 2 w/ Haley as the winner. :p Scotty and Lauren can sing but they're pretty boring. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
I was shocked and disappointed that James got voted off. I really feel that the majority of the voters must not like rock music. I happen to really like Scotty but I would have liked James to win. I will be rooting for Scotty to win now. I don't care for either of the girls and would probably not buy their music but I would definitely buy a Scotty cd. Scotty is just very young and I think he will only get better. |
You ALL know I don't like country music. BUT who of the three left has the best voice? Even I can appreciate what comes out of Scotty's mouth. He is consistent and true to his music. I have never heard him sing off key or forget lyrics. I liked James' personality and story better than Scottie James frequently hit sharp or flat notes as do the girls. I figure Scottie to win this competition. Fortunately after this is all over I won't have to watch his eyebrows going up and down as he sings out of the corner of his mouth. The limp wrist is even getting tiresome. Who do I now want to win? ...... Lauren. Haley's attitude ruined it for me. And I don't think Lauren is a fake I just don't think she can act as well as the others. And they all have been acting for the supposedly candid stuff. |
Oh and by the way, James was voted off because I was cheering for him. |
I didn't like Haley's attitude but she is from a town close by me. My daughter wanted James to win, but she heard about Haley's hometown visit and got 5 free tickets to her 1 hour show tomorrow. Maybe I'll see my dd on the show next week in the audience> lol |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I'm over it now, and my local friends are forming a boycott AI group to have a pizza/beer/wine party on Wed. & Thurs nights and we'll listen to music we love and not turn on the TV. Who wants to come???? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I wish the judges had kept the save and i bet they do to |
Imo Quote:
At least they know for next time. Randy did a poor job of showing the new judges the ropes. Don't get me wrong, I love them both but this was their 1st go at it and Steven and Jennifer are all heart. I feel like they let their emotions and personal relationship with the contestants cloud their judgment and keep them from giving them any real criticism which I think in turn is the reason America got it wrong this round ..there was no real guidance for or from anyone. I didn't think I missed Simon, but I wonder how things would have differed if he was still on the show. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Me to i miss Simon |
I am anxious to see what happens tonight. Scotty mentioned last week that he might sing a song while playing the piano. That might be interesting. I can't get as excited about it now since James was voted off. I like Scotty better than the two girls so for now he is my favorite, then Lauren, then Haley. |
Quote:
It just won't be the same since James isn't there. |
It isn't going to be the same without James:( |
You are right it was not the same, but i will say that Haley had it going on tonight Lauren did a good job on ( I hope you dance) but that song will be remembered for years like others that stayed forever |
I recorded AI and then fast forwarded through it. It was okay. Lauren was still cute, Haley was okay, Scotty, I just can't get into and can't stand to watch. I enjoyed watching The Voice that I had recorded. Think they have more talent and a lot more fun to watch. I'm also looking forward to X Factor. |
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:10 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright ©2003 - 2018 YorkieTalk.com
Privacy Policy - Terms of Use