Quote:
Originally Posted by TeresaM
(Post 2266208)
I respectfully disagree. The blame for this incident is squarely on the parents. Personality disorder or not, this is a 7 year old child running loose creating havoc. At this age where he is, what he is doing...anything and everything he does is his parents responsibility. All the more so if he does have a disorder, his parents are surly aware of it and must not allow him out without adequate supervision. He is not just a minor but a small child, his parents are 100% totally responsible for his safety and actions. The fact is, he should have never had the opportunity to do so much harm. What if, heaven forbid, he had a friend with him and he pushed that child in to the croc pen? It's not just what he did, but when he did it, "early Wed morning" and how, as a 7 year old, he was able to get there.
The report does not say if the parents had noticed him missing and were looking for him. Or how far they lived from the zoo. I would like to know that. How is a 7 year old child, "early Wed morning" able to leave home without being missed?
I did hear that because of his age he can not be prosecuted, but that they were going to pursue all legal avenues against the parents. I think that is reasonable and justified. If the parents are not able to protect the child or the public from the child then something needs to be done. |
I am not an expert, I'm just someone that's 2 semesters away from a masters degree in clinical social work (with a psychology background). I don't pretend to know all that there is about mental health and I certainly don't know a lot about children, developmental stages, etc.
That was just my opinion and I am respectful of anyone that agrees or disagrees with what I said. I do agree with you in that any child that does horrible things should place some responsibility (not necessarily blame) on their parent(s). Especially at such a young age, a parent should have control and know enough of where their child is and what his behaviors/mental health status is.
That said, having worked with
very troubled kids, that had very scary criminal records and lots of "bad" disorders, there's only so much anyone can do sometimes. Sadly, that includes the child his or her self, the parents, and any others involved. I've watched kids that were out of control, their parents were actively trying to work through things (which is sadly rare with problematic children, more often then not the parents are not just ambivalent they are actually problematic and cause even more issues) and the only thing to stop the child was police involvement. (And then sometimes the police were only able to help with that specific outburst.) But again, it's all very individualized to each person. I've generalized a lot and feel the need to make sure that I make it clear that there was very little information provided in the article. I made some assumptions in my original opinions and could be well off the mark just from that. But I also don't know the entire story to make any real assessment.
Someone that truly has Antisocial Personality Disorder has little hope. There's very little that can be done to stop them and there's very little that can be done to "help" them. Many times the most effective things are imprisonment and restricted care such as hospitalization. Actually, someone that has APD and it's a severe case would think just as much of hurting and torturing an animal as they would a person. So in the scheme of things who's to say this child hasn't already started to harm other people. Signs of APD are childhood torture/mutilation of animals, harming of peers, and setting fires. He seems to fit at least one of those three, who knows if he has done any of the others.
I guess the biggest thing I feel the need to voice, is that a person with a severe personality disorder such as APD
cannot control their actions. If asked about doing the acts they do a person may respond to the effect of "I knew I was doing it but I couldn't stop". And a full blown psychopath does not know the difference between right and wrong. And talking about people like Dahmer and Bundy, people with such disorders
are capable of deceiving the people around them and not "slipping up" until they do. There are people with disorders that I personally title "insanely smart" since they are able to manipulate and deceive people so amazingly.
But again, that's all my opinion and I'm not yet an expert on any of this, so I take full responsibility that any of what I've said may not be fully accurate.
Edited to add: While not a great resource, for anyone that wants to know a little bit about APD and what I'm talking about you can look here:
Antisocial personality disorder - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia