| Pinehaven | 08-20-2008 03:00 PM | Quote:
Originally Posted by yorkiekist
(Post 2193188)
This is a breed registry, but the breed standard has color restrictions. Most breed standards do. So, basically what you are saying is that it is ok to breed a blue and tan Biewer and show it and its ok to breed a non-masked Rott and show it and it would be ok to breed and show a black brindle Labrador also. These are all known colors that have been known to crop up in these breeds and the blue and tan is directly related to the Biewer and is in the gene pool. Do you think that the parent club of these breeds are just going to change the standard for the people that want to breed outside the standard? Why cant I show a blue and tan Biewer? Because the Biewer standard says I cant. Any ETHICAL Biewer breeder does not breed dogs that are not to the written standard. Same as all the other breeds, including the Yorkie. Why do you think its ok to breed outside the Yorkie standard? Thats what I dont understand. |
I can't comment on the Biewer questions since there are a number of Biewer registries with different rules and I don't know if any allow Biewer (parti gene) carriers to show in classes.
Again, standards for many breeds were written years ago prior to the scientific knowledge and DNA testing that we have today. If you review the YTCA's website, it states that:
"One of the reasons for avoiding breeding "off-colored" Yorkies is because it could be a genetic defect that may affect the dog's health. Some health problems can include, but aren't limited to, severe skin problems, allergies, total hair loss and in some cases long-term illness and/or death."
With the exception of the blue born yorkies, we know that the above statement is false. The other off colored yorkies are no more prone to health or illness problems, than the standard yorkies are. So that reason, for not breeding off colors, is a poor reason. This sounds like something people in the early 1900's would have thought because they knew no better; back in those days, that's what they were told, that off colors were genetically damaged, weak and unhealthy.
An ETCHIAL breeder (as you stated) does not breed dogs that are not to the written standard" but unfortunately, many YTCA members have been breeding outside the standard for years and will probably continue to do so in the future. Red leg, black and tan and yorkies with dark golden points have been used and will most likely continue to be used, in breeding programs to enhance the color of their show stock. So why is it ok to breed, raise and sell some off colored yorkies but it's not ok to breed, raise and sell other off colored stock? That's what I don't understand? |