I think we have heard from both parties and really it could or can be resolved between the two of them. I personally don't see a reason to continue to keep this thread open. JMO

Wow. Wow.

I can't believe I made it through that very long letter to Amanda. For someone who has no time to post, she certainly had quite a lot of time to write the letter. I wish she had just put the letters she said she has from the vet and the police, saying she is not a puppymill, her puppies are healthy, well cared for and well groomed on her site instead of quite so long of a letter to Amanda. That is what I would do -- post the evidence if you have it. They would hold a lot more weight than any post or letter from the breeder.

This will probably always be a "she said/she said" situation, but I just don't see what anyone would have to gain by trying to warn people against a breeder. If there was nothing to it, why would anyone make it up? I won't come right out and say one way or another though as only those who have been there can say for sure.

Whew, glad I'm staying out of this one. It is, whatever it is.

Thread should be closed imho.

Between the two of them now.

Anyone else notice that the two people that came to the defense of birdhouse are both banned???

they were the same person, the breeder.

so how come the breeder's original account was not also banned?

I am new here, but, have been lurking for quite awhile. I felt I should join, if for no other reason, to tell the truth as I have seen it. I dont' know this Amanda, and I am not personal friends with Ms Hall, but, I do have 2 of her babies. I have been to Ms Halls house a total of 2 times. I was so impressed with my first little girl, that I bought another one. Now, I don't care who believes me, you know the saying, there are always 3 sides to every story, her side, her side ant the truth;). I can say ms Hall is nothing like this OP makes her out to be. This woman is very caring, she loves her babies, and they love her back. Her house was spotless, wish mine only looked half that clean. People wonder why she doesn't post, I can tell you, this woman could probably run circles around most of us. She is very busy, and I'm surprised to be honest with you, that she can find 10 min a day to actually sit at her computer. Having 1 post or having 10,000 doesn't make you a liar or an honest person:confused:. I imagine Amanda has more time to sit and post than Ms Hall. I just couldn't believe everyone saying negative things about her without knowing her. How many of you know Amanda in person? Let me tell you a couple things I have found, just from reading. One, she uses her I'm married to a cop a lot..And, that means what? I have 7 family members that are in law enforcement. I have one that can travel from Point A to Point B a lot quicker than any of us, because, he's a cop. The things he gets pulled over for and then let go of, well, lets just say, the rest of us would be sitting in jail for. We also had a cop in my hometown, whos wife was found not to be "all that". She thought because she was married to "a cop" that she could get away with things, but, it didn't work out that way. Now, I'm not saying anything bad about ms Amanda, because, as I stated, I don't know her from Adam, just like everyone else in here. I think what she has said about Ms Hall is a vicious lie(as I said, I have met Ms Hall, and I feel she has been lied about). The sad thing, is a wonderful breeder who loves her dogs and takes better care of them than a lot of non breeders, has had her reputation ruined because of this slander. I am sorry this is such a long post, hope I don't get ridiculed for not making new paragraphs. I am just so upset that this has gone on like it has. I hope to make new friends here. i have read so much bashing in the last few weeks of lurking, it's ridiculous. Ms Hall, if you read this, please know that I always truely believe in what goes around comes around.

Omg!
 

Just read yr old thread on this women, omg I hope she is kick out of yt no way can we as member be right by this.
U r my angel, thanks for helping this precious furbaby, she needed help.
She looks just like my Max which I got fr a friend , cause he couldn't keep him, he had lost his job his home and on top of that he got sick. So he visit Max when ever he needs a kiss and now am on vac in NY and my vet calls me on a lady I meet a yr ago with a male yorkie and , I try to help with alllllll the questions she had , but it didn't work out so I get a call she want me to keep him. I just stated my own little rescue at home. Lol:D As soon as i pick him up I will post his pictures , I haven't seen him in a yr, but my vet said it's not the dog it's the owner Lol:p, this person should have a bigger dog.
well ! thank-u for the heads up on this woman.
bark@ulater!
manina, miley:aimeeyork, max:aimeeyork

Well said
 

:thumbup::thumbup: Bump!! Well said I'm on yr side why would Amanda wait a yr, I'm on her side. Bump !

bark@ulater!
manina, miley:aimeeyork, max :aimeeyork

NO she is cleaning !!! LOL
 

:pNo , she is cleaning up her mess!!!!
bark@ulater!!!!
manina,miley:aimeeyork, max:aimeeyork

At this points it's best to let sleeping dogs lie, my opinion.

I agree, I did not want to post here but I can see how there can be truths and lies on both side and let them fight it out.

all i can say is "wow" hope this one get's worked out soon?!

I agree in letting them fight it out, but don't think they need to use YT to do it. :D