X Factor Just wandering if anyone elso on here watches X Factor besides me. If so who are you rooting for??? I'm a Melanie Amaro Fan myself! :rolleyes: |
Yup. Very happy with the decision to kick the last person off just now. ;) Josh or Melanie would be fine with me. |
Quote:
Lol me too! I was like Paula... Send her HOME... her save me performance was a little rocky. |
I didn't care for Drew, either. Am I the only person who isn't crazy about Rachel Crow? She has a good voice. She gives it her all when she preforms. But, I don't like to watch her. |
I'm a Melanie fan, too. And Josh has grown on me every week. I'd pay to see him in concert. Rachel's cute and talented but no $5 million star right now. I think I prefer the Idol setup with judging to this one. They don't give honest appraisals because they're rooting for their own people. Then they get vindictive when someone criticizes their singers and take it out on the other judge's singer. They're really acting like children, pretty much all of them. I'm glad Astro's gone. I don't think it was a good type of contest for him. Rappers are bad boys, and no one wants a kid to act like a bad boy. I thought his music suffered when he got repentent about his little hissy fit the first week he was in the bottom 2. I love Drew's voice, but she came off as way too one-dimensional. Reminded me of a young Haley on the recent idol. Same type of voice, same lack of range. I love the adult rapper's story and attitude, but he's not one of my favorites. |
Well, I was for Stacy Francis and I'm sad she got kicked off. Astro was cute and interesting until he acted like a baby. Drew was interesting (but I wasn't a fan of her vocal style). I just don't think she fit into this venue. She seems like she would do better in a singer songwriter type of contest (which they should make a show like that). Marcus Canty and Chris Rene have got to go. They are far from original. Very boring if you ask me and Chris cannot sing very well. Rachel Crow is cute, has a great voice but cannot compete with Melanie. She will do well on the Disney channel though. Josh is good but again he just doesn't hold a candle to Melanie. I think Melanie is going to win it all because of how Simon went back to get her and it's his show. He wants to be the "Hero that saved the star" Simon is wayyyyy to into himself to let it be any other way. Since his show Pop Idol was cancelled he wants to show he can bring a star to life...well, at least that's what I think hehe. Who knows! I think that the next to go will be Rachel or Josh the way things are going but I hope it's Marcus. I believe the final 2 will be Chris and Melanie. |
I like Josh and Melanie. I think I would probably buy more cd's from Josh though. Im disappointed that Drew was voted off. I think she could probably be big like Taylor Swift. Thats kinda who she reminded me of. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Josh is my favorite. then Melanie. i do still like Rachel Crow but she's not as good as them, she's so cute though, love her pesonallity and she does sing good. Also liked Drew. |
Oops, I meant Astro, not Drew. ONe of the major problems that I have with shows like this is the fact that the judges appear to be lacking in ability to know who is good and who is not. There have been some absolutely off performances that are called "good". I also can't stand how the best person doesn't get voted for because somebody else is hot or cute (although..truth be told I woulda voted for Brennon ;) ). Rachel Crow is a very good singer for her age. She is not and never was a great singer. I don't understand how she can still be on there. |
I cant believe marcus got through and rachel didnt..grrrrr |
Quote:
He did?? (I have it on DVR and have yet to watch it)... This may sound cruel, but I was hoping he would go home. |
Marcus, Rachel, and Chris all need/needed to go home. IMO, only two people on there are good enough for a five million dollar deal |
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:55 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright ©2003 - 2018 YorkieTalk.com
Privacy Policy - Terms of Use