American Idol this week! *Possible spoilers in this thread, so be warned!* What are your thoughts so far? I'm a little more judgemental than I usually am this week. :p Seyesha...I could definetly see her on Broadway in the future. If The Color Purple was still playing I could easily have seen her in the lead part. Jason....yeah. No. Sorry to his fans, but I was in pain. Brooke...meh. Not bad. I'm a fan of her's, but I'm not overwhelmed. David...nicely done. It took me a minute to get over the shock of him changing that song...but I thought he really did a good job with it. people comment a lot on how he's exactly what you hear on the radio as if its a bad thing. I would think its a good thing - he's got what it takes to get his music played. I'd just like to point something out. Simon would always use having "a 'Broadway voice'" as an insult. These people - who are otherwise amazing singers - seem to be having a problem singing Broadway music. Your thoughts so far? |
nothing impressive so far this week. i didn't like what brooke did in the beginning of her song. seyesha i could definitely see her on broadway. Carly is definitely going to get a record deal out of this show because her voice IS amazing and strong. not really a fan of david a, he's just to "cute-sie" for my taste. my opinion on david c to come in the next 5 minutes :D |
Quote:
|
Megan did you like David Cook ? I thought his performance was phenomenal. |
My favs in order: 1. David Cook 2. Carly Smithson 3. David Archuletta I think thats how they will finish as well. Jason and Brooke....like you said, eh. I see Brooke doing like a Carly Simon vibe. And Syesha, we WILL see her on broadway. Thats where she shines. IMO I love Lord Andrew Lloyd Webbers music. hes amazing. |
My thoughts.... David C - awesome Carly - liked it a bunch David A - sang well, but I still think that he is way too cheesy Brooke - Yep she messed up big time Syesha - Very nice... she looked wonderful Jason - OK.. singing C+..... but he still is SUCH a cutie!! :p |
DAVID COOK! How do I love thee? He is INCREDIBLE. That was beyond amazing. I almost cried watching it...no joke. Usually David A gets my vote. But I'll have to be unfaithful to my future hubby for tonight and vote for David Cook. He is just overly deserving this week. |
Quote:
|
My top 3 1. David Cook 2. David Cook 3. David Cook :thumbup: btw he's been my pick since day one!! |
Quote:
|
For your listening pleasure |
Thanks for posting the vid, Joan. I was at the computer and didn't catch all of David' performance. It was better than I thought. He's been my favorite for the last several weeks. His voice beat out his lack of personality in my book. I'm with Megan on the rest. That was Seyesha's best night. I loved it. Jason, painful. What was he thinking? Why did they let him do that? Carly, I'm so glad she changed songs. But is it just me or was she not in sync with the backup singers? Brook, my wife loves her, but she does nothing for me. David A, he's great but doesn't have the edge that David C. has. He's gotten boring to me. |
David A. is my favorite. he has an innocence to him that makes you want to hug him... but he's also a great singer. I like Jason because of his personality, but he won't win... :( he's very cute though. lol. I think brooke should get kicked off (no offense). but i don't think she's the best singer on the show. she has her moments, and she's emotionally connected to the songs she sings, but she doesn't compare to other contestants. I like Carly a lot... but she often chooses the wrong songs. but i enjoyed her performance last night (jesus christ superstar). I think Seyesha has a good voice, but I never really like her performances. and she doesn't stick in my mind. Last but not least, David C. I have to disagree with those who like him. i'm not saying he's not a good singer, but i don't think he's the best. I heard on the radio that Randy thinks it's going to come down to the two Davids in the finale. he's probably right. Let's see... tonight's bottom three? Jason, Brooke, and a toss up between Carly and Seyesha. |
David Cook all the way tonight! I wish they told you who the top vote getter was each week. Carly was good-yeah Mike, she covered herself well but I don't think she meant to be singing different words than her back up. And as for my future son-in-law, well, David A could sing the phone book and I'd love it. I just love his voice. Seyesha was good....but she sounded just like every other out-of-work broadway singer. (sorry megan) Jason and Brooke pack your bags. I used to like Brooke but I can see she is very one-dimensional. Like Randy keeps saying if you can sing you can sing anything. She can only sing that Carly Simon/Carol King way. And when she tries to look sexy-eyed into the camera, well, it just looks like her contacts are loose. |
I so wanted the last two to be. David Cook and Michael Johns but :( |
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:01 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright ©2003 - 2018 YorkieTalk.com
Privacy Policy - Terms of Use