Teresa Ford | 12-23-2011 07:30 AM | Labs and Yorkies .. different oh yessss
In the 70s and 80s we bred, trained, showed and were involved with Labs. We even worked with service dog trainers for the blind and physically impaired. As a breed I would feel safe in the general statement, Labs want to work for people. They thrive on praise and reward type training. Of course there are always exceptions. I Do not think (forgive me this is not mean to start rebuttals) Labs are on the high end of intelligence. They would rather someone else be the rule maker and leader. Nor would I consider them independent thinkers or problem solvers. Well trained Labs are are amazing. Once they get past the long puppy stage and reach maturity Labs make wonderful, faithful, companions. NOW Yorkies are a different sort of dog. I found that out when I started working with them in the 1980s. Some were treat motivated, some weren't. Smart ? You bet ! Not smart like German Shep. or Border Collies (Who I think are smartest dogs ever) Yorkies seem to know how to get what they want. I have seen Yorkies change assertive behavior to begging and submissive to get what they want. Perhaps it is because they have spent so many centuries as companions and lived with people, in their home. I think Yorkies do what people want them to, when it pleases them to do so. I think they understand training perfectly, but it is secondary to what they want. I am teasing a bit, but really I think Yorkies are very human, they have so many of our finer behaviors, like love, loyalty, and compassion. But they can also be temperamental, moody, selfish, possessive, and self important. I have enjoyed training them for almost 30 years. I never use a harsh tone, firm voice, but not harsh. I also use a lot of praise and physical touch when working with Yorkies. Physical comfort I think is far more important to Yorkies. Labs can bash into a garden wall while playing, or dive into icy water and barely notice. Yorkies cringe when it rains or they have a knot in their fur. I think their sense touch is very close to our own. I often have to remind people to let Yorkies walk. They tend to carry them way too much. Yorkies can become wonderful, well trained companions as well as any Lab.
I kind of think about it like this, a Lab is like a not so bright child may be a joy to parent, and so easy to love. They obey the rules and seldom cause a problem. When they are an adult they will be hard working, kind and fit into society perfectly.
Yorkies are like, an independent, intelligent, and creative child. They may drive you crazy and challenge your authority. They study human behavior and know how to get people to work for them. As a teenager they may do some dangerous and experimental things. When they mature they still retain their child like curiosity and fun nature. As adults they really listen and care about the WHY of everything. They are never boring, and you love having long conversations with them, because they do understand the delicate, and subtle things about life. |