Quote:
Originally Posted by Nancy1999  It's funny, but I think everyone here, besides me, thinks the mother is lying. I'm just not as sure of that part as all of you, but if the jury thinks like the majority of Yorkietalkers, they are going to think she's lying too.
With me, her testimony didn't change my mind enough to show Casey is innocent. I think what we are really talking about is, “Was the act premeditated?” I do not think the state has ever shown that, I do think she gave her different drugs when she went out to party, and may have even kept her in the trunk when she was visiting her boyfriends. She’s told people before that she gave her daughter drugs to make her sleep. Why the state didn’t make these people testify, I don’t know, it’s almost like the state thought that might show it could have been accidental? Maybe the other drugs weren't working as well any longer and she gave her something stronger, chloroform? Was the taping of the mouth to keep her quiet, who knows, but, even so, this is such extreme abuse, that she deserves to be severely punished? I’m also upset that she seems to be making up the story about the drowning and her father’s involvement, as an former police officer, I just don’t buy that he’d ever do this, and if so, it wouldn’t be this sloppy. He also would have never told police officers that his own car smelled like a dead body.
I’ve read of other “mothers” keeping their children in the trunk, while they did their own thing, and if Casey slept in too long in the morning, and left her daughter in the trunk, with the Florida sun, it would have killed her.
How many of you think it was premeditated, and why? |
You know, I'm not sure it was premeditated. I'm not sure if she just knocked her out to party and it was too much and she died, that may be the case.
What I'm having a hard time wrapping my head around is how her attorney throws out to the world that her dad and brother sexually abused her, and the dad dumps the body, but they are supporting her. I really don't get that. How is it the father and brother would not be outraged that someone is alleging such horrendous acts?? It makes no sense unless there is something seriously disturbing being covered up.
Maybe when she discovered the child dead, she did tell them at the time and they helped cover it up and now they are trying to avoid something coming back on them.
Why on earth are they testifying about baby showers and stuff surrounding her birth! What does this have to do with her death
