I had the same experience listed above. I thought Innova might be the best of those 3, but my four would not eat it. They all like ChickenSoup, but then I need separate Puppy and Adult foods and they still get in each others all the time. So, now I am using Canidae for all of them. Works well for us, except for the availability. I cannot find it locally and have to order it online. We ran out and I had to substitute some Natural Balance and Merrick's -- they are not liking it. |