I have tried all three foods you mentioned and this is what I found....
Innova: none of my dogs liked this, they didn't care for the flavor at all and wouldn't eat it.
Chicken soup: it was great, all the dogs loved it and it really helped their skin and coat.
Canidae: I just switched from Chicken Soup to Canidae about a week ago. The dogs love the taste and it is also suppose to be good for their skin and coat. The actually like it better than the CS because when I started switching them to Canidae, they would pick out and eat all the Canidae kibble and leave the Chicken Soup kibble alone. The only reason I switched from Chicken Soup to Canidae is because Canidae is for all life stages. I have two puppies that get puppy food, 4 get adult food and one gets Senior food. So rather than buying 3 different bags like I normally do and trying to make sure each dog eats the right food, I just buy one bag and they all eat the same food.
So for my dogs, they liked the Canidae the best and didn't like Innova at all.
Hope this helps you some!! |