Well, I FINALLY found something. I went to store close by (prestigiouspets.com) and I explained to the owner the problem I was having. She suggested this little small stuffed toys with long arms (for chewing). She has 3 yorkies and said these all worked for them. I took it home and OMG she loved it

We played for a good while and it was a lot of fun to see that side of her that I have not seen yet. Thank you all for your help and suggestions.
BTW, Des I would love to have another little one, but my husband would KILL me (HAHA). He says one is enough for us (I like to spend too much $ on her).
Thanks,
Courtney