I just found this thread and I'm glad I did because I'm totally sold on this Laura M stuff. I was already making up a sephora order so it was perfect timing too (you know the with the $75 free shipping). But I have no clue what color to get. We don't have half the stuff on Sephora in Albuquerque that's why I order it online. So I'm wondering how much of a difference there is between the shades? I'd hate to spend that much and get the wrong color.

They all look very similar on the website.
I agree, Bare Essentials wasn't what I hoped either. It feels different than you'd expect and it looked orange on me.