What about a nice watch? I got Jim a Movado for our 2 year anniversary and he loves it. Or what about some sexy lingerie? hehehe
Ok seriously, what about an official jersey of his favorite player or better yet, make HIM a scrap book!! Jim did that for me for our 1 year anniversary and I just about died. It was full of pictures, movie stubs of movies that we went to see together, broadway ticket stubs (like of Aida and Beauty and the Beast), a rose from the first dozen roses he ever bought me pressed into the book, a pair of chop sticks I used when we went to this really trendy Japanese restaurant and just anything else that we collected together. It was so awesome!!