Baby eats Bil-Jac and she loves it....my breeder sent her home with some and I have never changed. In my opinion it's not low on the "totem pole" but I'm sure it's not on the top either. It is a good dog food, and if everyones dogs love it, then I think it's good. I have heard that it's easy to rank dog food by looking at the ingredients. In Bil-Jac...3 of the first 4 ingredients are some sort of chicken, whether it's just chicken or chicken by product. So, it's good for me...and I'm glad it's good for you guys too!