Rexy and Rowdy have the same buddy lookout carseat (but in beige for boyz!) and we got ours from Tinkerbells' Closet too! They love it - of course Rowdy would rather be in his console lookout that we had before we got Rexy
My only problem is that they want to move from one side to the other sometimes and the straps get crossed. I have some giant safety pins and so I just pin each strap to the seat belt so that they can't switch sides - works like a charm.
On long trips, both of them just go to sleep and this carseat is ideal!!!