Well he is just the cutest thing! I understand the shock of the first cut. That is not really a puppy cut..it's more of a schnauzer cut. Still stinkin adorable.
Best bet is to take a pic of what you want next time. Or...do it yourself. So far, I just do it myself. I've heard too many unhappy customers from groomers.
Edit to add: if you go to my profile page and look at Mandie's early pics..this cut is similar. The owners before me had that done and called it a "modified schnauzer"