I have to say that I'm a RC fan. Louie had diarrhea a couple of weeks ago (I was feedinghim Eukanuba at the time) and the vet told me to give him chicken and rice-after that he didn't want to touch dry food or any kind of dog food for that matter (even the wet one) until I switched to RC. I tried Innova, solid gold, eukanuba, cesars...all he wanted was chicken! Thank godness I found RC because I was very concerned that he wasn't getting the % of nutrients and fat that he needs during his growing stage. So, I guess everyone will have their personal favorite, I would really just see what works for your particular pup.