Well I went and did it
I ordered the Acana Duck and Pear!! I should get it Friday!!
Hopefully Peanut does well on it. I was going to get the Lamb and Apple, but I read that Lamb meat is fattier than red meat! It said the leanest lamb meat is fattier than a piece of red meat.... So I would love to have Peanut loose a couple pounds, so I went with the Duck. Not as fatty- so we will see what happens!