Congrats on your new car! I have always had Farm Bureau Insurance because they were affiliated with the organization my father worked for. FB Insurance is very reasonable, much cheaper than Allstate. I think you have to sign up for a Farm Bureau membership with an annual fee of approx $25. You don't have to be a farmer.
We have only submitted 2 claims in the 25 years that we have used them, but they were great both times. My convertible was broken into and the thieves broke a window, stole my stereo, and ripped up my dashboard. Farm Bureau was fast and generous with processing the claim.