Zhoie eats TOTW Pacifica too. She loves anything fish flavor. I tried Acana but she wasn't to fond of it. I had a little concern over the higher protein in Acana anyway, so she decided for us
So we are sticking with TOTW for as long as she still goes nuts for it. We add about 1/2 teaspoon of chicken flavor Weruva can food and she does circles all the way to the sunroom where she eats. This a winner for us.