Mayonnaise all the way...yum yum. I don't like the sweet tangy taste of Miracle Whip. I am weird I don't like foods to have a sweet taste (hate sweet and sour) unless it is dessert. I like sweet foods just not for the main meal. If something has a sweet taste I eat it last like a dessert. I also can't stand for my foods to touch on my plate or juices from one food to run into another....told you I am weird