KendraE yes its very aggravating and we too couldnt catch Izzy in the act they are very sneeky! Today we are having a good day sooo far!! We did crate train but over the past couple of years have not used the crate at all... but I have resorted to her sleeping in her crate at night and putting her in it when we are not home it breaks my heart esp at night but I know she will not potty in her crate so if it helps solve the problem then I guess that is what we will have to do I put 2 of the kitchen rugs back down today after they had been washed and we will see what happens as these were her FAVORITE potty spots this past week! Fingers are crossed!