[FlDebra]

Originally Posted by ladyjane

Well, as I said, we all read and interpret things differently. I am not going to go on and on ad ininitum on this. No need for that. You seem to have taken this very personal and I am sorry you feel that way. ???? Really??? I have taken this personal? Only to the point, I would really like only my own words attributed to me.

Yes, it is the YT Seller Review and Feedback forum and people will post what they feel. So why is it wrong for others to post how THEY feel? Now, I am beginning to take this personal! I felt that it got to be a bit harsh....but I was crystal clear in saying that that was how *I* read it. That does NOT mean that is how anyone meant for it to be taken.

I see that you are taking it personal, although I haven't a clue as to why.
Okay -- I have no problem with you wanting to read it however you want. But when you say this is how you read it, and another person feels that is not how they meant it, isn't it fairly normal for them to say so?

All I can say is WOW. What a disappointment.

Okay again -- but I am not sure how my critique of a product that you have nothing to do with has set you up for such disappointment.

Sarah is not a friend of mine. I don't even know her nor have I used her products. I have seen her here but have never had any type of real conversation with her. I simply posted MY feelings about the thread. I did NOT say that no one should ever give a negative review. It's all how you read things I suppose. I used to give reviews to employees and if I had given them huge capital letters of THUMBS DOWN just because of one aspect of their job performance, how would that have helped them? It wouldn't!
I am done now. Clearly this has been taken to a new place where it should not have been.

You do realize that I did NOT make the thumbs down comment, right? I have given my share of performance reviews myself, and you can rest assured, I never gave anyone a capitalized thumbs down either. But why are you shaking a finger at me for this?

I am only taking it personal to the point that I do not want my comments misconstrued or changed. I had some very valid comments about a product that I DID try. I held my public comments for over a year but when I did make them, I made them with respect. I have no idea why you are now telling me all of these things or why you are saying what a disappointment. I never said you were a friend of anyone, a consumer of the shampoo, never said anyone could not give a negative review or any of the other things you seem to be insinuating?????? To tell you the truth, I thought WE were well on our way to becoming friends. So, I find this all very surprising, unsettling, and confusing. I think you took this to another place and I did not go along with you. I am sure no one will want to voice a negative comment on this product again and subject themselves to this, no matter how they feel. So, we could probably move on now, if it's okay with you. Believe me, I am not saying you have to. Whew!