[Reese1]

Originally Posted by bellababy08

I haven't been on YT very long...but how is it fair to criticize one person for breeding a 4.5 lb girl and than applaud another in breeding a 4.5 lb girl and using a 2.5 lb stud. http://www.yorkietalk.com/forums/ima.../paperclip.gif Announcing the birth of Duchess and Sebastian's 5 babies! IMO there is nothing ethical about either one but yet they are both being treated differently. I don't mean to offend anyone just stating a fact!!

I'm not applauding that breeder either. I personally didn't see that thread, but I see the red flags on that website as well. Not only the 4.5 girl that is bred now, but one that is only 3.5lb.
Both girls are too small by most reputable breeders recommendations.
I don't think the people that responded to this one are reacting differently to the other, they are probably like myself and haven't seen that one.