He is better with the normal clicker. I ordered a soft clicker I think he just needed some getting used to. Before he was so scared of it he just cowered but now he will eat a treat. He is wary of going through the tire jump in agility since the trainer would use the clicker. Poor guy

. I have a lot of dogs here for a holidays so once they leave I can focus on his training more. I need to boil some chicken that will definitely help.