I'm not going to debate this because I am only responsible for the well being of my girl, but please realize that there are 146 pages of reviews on this food and a whole lot of them aren't favorable. Yes, every food has it's problems, but this is far from just a little stomach upset. The symptoms are rumored to be identical to zinc toxicity which is a funny thing since their cat food was recalled not long ago for that very thing. This isn't about ingredients. In fact, Nutro has good ingredients compared to some foods. This is about unexplained illness and death. There have even been a couple reports on YT about this. It's very sad to see that the warnings aren't being taken seriously.
And maybe it has been blown way out of proportion and nothing is wrong with the food, but I can't imagine taking that chance with my girl.