I see some wrong on each side too. I think it is very difficult to sell internationally unless affiliated with a dog club of some kind that could have members on both sides to vouch for the seller and buyer.
I think they are saying different things about her accepting a different puppy as one of the two she chose died and the other was too tiny to ship out for possible breeding. He said: "
and because I´m very responsable persons I sent to Peggy my own puppy that one which I was choose for to keep for my self , I explain that to her and she was agree and happy with the new girl , "
The 2 pound puppy is only 18 weeks old. She might make it up to 5 pounds, although it will probably be more like 3 pounds, so you are right, no one should have sold or bought her as a breeding prospect. If no one wants her, send her to me!
I think if the buyer was unhappy with her first purchase, she would not hjave gone through all of the trouble to buy another puppy from an out-of-country seller. I think if the seller was that unhappy with the buyer on the first purchase, he should not have thought she was improving enough to sell her another. So, they must not have been that unhappy with each other on the male purchase. It was with this little female, bad feelings developed. Why? Is it because she is a different female than originally picked? Not as pretty as the first ones? Too little to breed? Why now is the seller mad? Did he not know that she was mixing breeds? Did he not know that she was wanting to breed this female?
Too many questions for me to even think about taking sides. I do think the buyer should get his pictures off her ads immediately. You do not steal pictures and use them without permission. If he was local to the her, it would be easy to sue her and take a percentage of every sale she makes with his pictures!
I think the seller should not sell anymore dogs until he can have a good reference from the people's vet and maybe for sales to the U.S. like this, require a YTCA member to vouch for them.
Unfortunately this sale is done, and there is probably little to be done. The buyer is only going to return the puppy if he pays for everything and that is probably going to be a huge expense for the seller. This is unfortunate because the seller's dogs look gorgeous! To have one even that has to be spayed for being too small to breed would be an honor.