Hi Reese
I know you mentioned that you have tried many other foods out there, did the pups like any of them?? I don't know why, but a company that allows their treats to made in China, does not sit well with me. Of course this is your decision and I respect that but has your lovely bunch tried Wellness, Merrick, TOTW, Artemis (will send tons of samples-awesome small breed formula), Fromm, Chicken Soup, California Natural, NV Praire, or Solid Gold?? With such a great reputation, there is little risk. Good luck, hope something entices those appetites!