I'm just the idea gal. I don't do practical!
I have a variety of stuff. Like I got this really nice set of muttluks I know Thor will never wear, and I have $0.99 rubber toys he ended up not liking.
Maybe we have a daisy chain? One person sends their stuff to another person, and when you get your box, you fill it up with YOUR unwanted stuff, and send it to the next person, etc. Or maybe you post for something you are looking for, say, chew toys, and someone offers to send you some, and it's up to you to find the next link in the chain. You can't get stuff until you've officially said you will send stuff to someone else.
OR, we could have some kind of clearing house, where everyone posts what they have, and people can ask for it. Again, you can't ask for stuff unless you are offering extras yourself.
Would that work?? Anyone else have ideas?
Personally, I am not really worried about the monetary value, but if that's an issue, we could post the rough market value of what we have. Kind of like a giant, virtual garage sale.