I've been doing that for years! I wash them in soapy water with bleach and if they make it through that cycle I wash them a second time. I only buy soft baby toys because I believe they are made with every intention of being chewed on by babies. I throw a lot of them away after that but I get them at a local thrift store that bundles a bunch of them in a bag for just a couple of dollars.
I bought a horse that actually whinnies and it made it through just fine. Cassie loves it. |