Thank you...I can see how it prob looks that way. The reason I have been inquiring so much is so I can narrow this down and you are right--I prob am creating a picky eater, but I can say, I am still mixing his new foods with his original Merrick Puppy Plate. He itches on his Puppy Plate so have been getting samples and trying them out. You're right--he did eat the Nature's Logic one day and then goes hungry for the next 3 days, I can't have that. We tried a bit of the EVO and his poops were so huge and scary and crazy that we stopped that after 4 days. Well the NB Venison has been good for the past 5 days and also THK in the mornings. He is still on antibiotics for a few more days, but 3 out of the 4 meds he was on are done. I'm pretty much set on my choice now, just wanted some feedback for some warnings if it's not a good choice. I just want to make the right choice....thank goodness I have not gone out and bought big bags of any of these.
-Vivian