oh dear...well to preface my opinion i know nothing about either breeder you are interested in, but the fact you are asking our opinion kind of tells me you have doubts or reservations...to be honest, based on what you said about both litters, i would pass on both...i would hate for you to feel like you are "settling" when your baby is going to be a part of your family for many many years to come...IMO you should keep looking - the perfect pup is out there for you