She was a year old on September 29, and we have the same problem. She pees outside 99% of the time, occasional accident, but the poopie thing well. That another story. She gets it right 10% of the time. thank god her poopie is firm or I would cry. If I could find a snack she likes I would try the snack training thing, but she doesn't like any snacks at this point. Still love her to death though.