Awww Marci could you REALLY take that bunny away from that face? Can you replace the squeaker and sew or patch the ripped spots?
Emma had a rubber squeaky glow in the dark frog as a puppy, she LOVED it. Well, she chewed him up beyond repair, and I got her a new one. It was never the same-but the old one wasn't safe any more

She did the same thing to her snuggle puppy (the kind of plush toy with a velcro pouch that you can put in the microwave to keep them warm at night). I sewed him up several times, and he's still alive..sort of!
Milli would be lost without her stuffed cupcakes-when I realized she loved the first one so much, I went and bought two more, so we will have cupcakes for a long time!