Quote:
Originally Posted by Yorkiefan49  Thought the show was good tonight! David A finally gained a little credit in my book! Ive always thought his voice was amazing, but I felt he lacked talent as far as his performance (dancing, opening eyes, etc). But tonight I think he delivered an all around great performance as a whole. He is really working hard and listening to criticism and I admire that! Good job young buck!!
David C still keeps me in awe....he IS the IDOL whether he wins or not.
Jason, time to go.....Brooke, shoulda been gone
and here is my Syesha theory!! I think Simon said tonight that he thought she was going home cuz he knows that the voting at this point is
BS!! SO....he said that so people will disagree and vote for
Syesha! Thus keeping her in the competition which she so deserved after her last two weeks performances!! So good thinking Simon!! Cuz there is NO WAY Simon in his right mind can say that to her and still support Brooke and Jasons less than good enough performances!
Again.....JMO!!  |
This is
just my humble opinion, I have not been on much about this season.
No one really has knocked my socks off. After
Michael Johns left, I felt talent was not an object.
Jason still sounds as he should be singing at a campfire. And I hope he gets sent there tonight.
Syesha is definitely in her element when she does show tunes.
Brooke may sell albums but her performances will be empty, she needs show presence.
David C. did a smart ting picking an unknown song so he could not be compared to anything. And he is just a amazing singer.
David A. chose a safe song with "
Coming to America" -- He did not rock it, but he did a good job. With time and maturity, he will do nicely. Melodic voice and he will do better when he ditches the "stage dad".
IMHO,
Jason should be packing his bags for Music Camp. And
Brooke will follow next week. Or visa versa. But neither will be in the top 3 (as far as I am concerned)
And let's not forget where is Taylor Hicks today?
And
Chris Daughtry? Rocking the night away! Selling out concerts, etc.